Transcript Highlights:

• Some house cleaning: we are going to hold House Bill 2118.
• has long been established but lacked a definition of the term firefighter, leading to a denial of a claim
• House Bill 2138 cleans up the statute and restores its original legislative intent, and we ask for your
• Unfortunately, this was not how the workers' compensation claim played out.
• His claim was denied due to the insurance company His claim was denied due to the insurance company exploiting

Bills: HB2091, HB2118, HB2122, HB2138

Keywords: insurance, financial surveillance, regulations, assessments, Arizona Revised Statutes, mobile food vendors, licensure, food safety, statewide regulations, health standards, zoning, temporary vendors, technical registration, engineering, architect, land surveyor, reciprocity, endorsement, qualification standards, firefighter

Transcript Highlights:

• These claims are largely unfounded.
• It should also exempt purely illustrative or thematic figures that make no claim about the product.
• We'd love to see it cleaned up and hopefully more conversations are held.
• It just got cleaned up recently. I mean, they didn't even clean it up quickly.
• And, frankly, with respect to the cleanup, I mean, who else should clean up the park?

Summary: The committee heard testimony on several bills, beginning with SB 16, which would require county behavioral health directors to create clear pathways for clinicians to be authorized to initiate 5150 involuntary holds. The author and supporters argued the bill would reduce reliance on law enforcement and create more consistent crisis response standards statewide, while county behavioral health directors opposed it as an unfunded mandate that could increase law enforcement involvement and create implementation burdens. Members raised questions about county costs and funding, but the author emphasized the bill’s role in building a more clinical response system. SB 561 would require public guardians to acknowledge conservatorship referrals, make determinations within a reasonable time, and provide status updates on request. Supporters said the bill would reduce delays that leave vulnerable adults in limbo, while the opposition from public guardian representatives was removed after amendments. SB 381 drew extensive public testimony in support; it would allow California-born adoptees, and descendants of deceased adoptees, access to original birth certificates, with a nonbinding contact preference form for birth parents. Supporters framed the bill as a matter of dignity, identity, and health, and there was no formal opposition on the record. The committee also discussed SB 880, which would give tenants and prospective owner-occupants notice and a first opportunity to make an offer when institutional investors sell certain homes. Supporters said it would expand homeownership opportunities and preserve neighborhood stability, while opponents warned about conflicts with federal law, bundled-sale restrictions, and impacts on build-to-rent and affordable housing projects. Members and the author discussed possible amendments to address those concerns. SB 1238 would impose a duty of care and additional transparency requirements on HOA managers and boards; supporters said it would protect homeowners from mismanagement, while the main opposition argued the duty should remain contractual and could increase litigation. Finally, SB 423 would require disclosure of emergency-service records related to private detention facilities, and SB 28 would make changes to the CARE Court process, including a statewide ombudsperson and expanded oversight; both drew support and opposition, with concerns focused on transparency, privacy, implementation, and the balance between treatment and coercion. SB 574, discussed at the end, would require disclosure and human oversight for AI use in courts and legal practice and create a complaint process for ADR providers, with the State Bar noting requested amendments related to complaint handling and confidentiality.

Transcript Highlights:

• </c><00:59:18.800><c> asylum</c> is when you come here and claim asylum is when you come here and claim
• We're talking about people you say they got here and they claimed asylum.
• We're talking about people you say they got here and they claimed asylum.
• We're talking about people you say they got here and they claimed asylum.
• We're talking about people you say they got here and they claimed asylum.

Keywords: 1183, house

Transcript Highlights:

• Again, things like cleanings and x-rays are available through Medicaid.
• It's a 53 percent increase in the number of claims we've processed over that time.
• claims.
• We enjoy that fight, and we self-monitor ourselves on that timeliness of claims.
• That's added to the number of claims we're able to process.

Summary: The Appropriations Committee on Health and Human Services heard a base budget overview for the 2025-26 fiscal year, which was presented as a $46.8 billion starting point for the silo. Staff explained that HHS accounts for about half of the state base budget and roughly 36% of general revenue, with AHCA and Medicaid making up the largest share. The committee then reviewed the PACE program for the elderly, including its eligibility, service model, growth in applications, slot funding and reversions, and the agency’s plan to move from the federal three-way agreement to a more detailed two-party contract to improve accountability, transparency, and reporting. Members raised concerns about unfilled slots, reversions, rural access, and the need for clearer return-on-investment data; the agency said it would follow up on some of those questions. The committee also heard from the Agency for Persons with Disabilities on its statewide dental program. APD described its history of appropriations, the failed January 2024 solicitation, and a new up-to-$11.5 million solicitation focused on preventive care, community partnerships, teledentistry, and coordination with other services. Members questioned overlap with Medicaid dental coverage, the effect of Medicaid unwinding on APD clients, and whether state dollars were duplicating federally supported services; APD said it tries to act as payer of last resort and that services would continue during procurement. Public testimony from an APD stakeholder and the Florida Dental Association emphasized Medicaid eligibility problems for waiver recipients, low reimbursement rates, limited access to anesthesia and hospital-based dental care, and concerns that proposed Medicaid changes could reduce access for special-needs patients. The Department of Veterans’ Affairs then presented on state veterans service officers and benefits assistance. FDVA highlighted its role in helping veterans access federal benefits, reporting about $27.9 billion in federal dollars flowing into Florida and a high return on state investment. The department said it has increased outreach, claims processing, and services, and has trained staff to identify mental health concerns through its Overwatch program. In response to questions, FDVA discussed plans to expand adult day health care at a new veterans nursing home and possibly at existing locations with additional state funding. At the end of the meeting, the committee completed its presentations and adjourned without objection.

Transcript Highlights:

• So do we claim the land that is on with the Spirit Lake Casino?
• They've cleaned it out one time, the cattails.
• You guys should be able to clean it out.
• So claim to the lake bed. How did the state come to claim the lake bed in Devil's Lake?
• Its claim to the inundated patent parcels.

Summary: The committee opened its third interim meeting with roll call, approved the November 13, 2025 minutes, and the chair reviewed prior committee work, including a denied request for a fertilizer-capacity study and a planned later discussion of the Union Pacific/Norfolk Southern merger issue. Commissioner Doug Goring then presented Department of Agriculture updates on uncrewed aerial systems grants to detect noxious weeds, the state’s irrigation potential, the low-carbon fuels program for ethanol plants, the Environmental Impact Mitigation Fund, model zoning ordinances for animal feeding operations, and fertilizer production and supply in North Dakota. Members asked about funding sources, fertilizer storage and availability, natural gas and water needs for future fertilizer plants, and how the model zoning website would help counties and townships apply setback and odor tools. A substantial portion of the meeting focused on the Department of Water Resources’ economic analysis tool for water conveyance and flood-related projects. Dr. Dwayne Poole explained that the department is proposing changes to better account for end-of-useful-life conditions and updated hydrologic data, while still limiting the model to direct, demonstrable costs and benefits. He said the goal is to make the analysis more realistic and consistent without changing statute, and he provided examples of how project benefits could change as drains age or as rainfall and flood data evolve. Committee members and water-user representatives generally supported continued work on the proposal, while raising concerns about downstream impacts, closed-basin projects, and whether the changes would meaningfully affect project approvals. The committee then heard from John Paskowski, state engineer, on Devil’s Lake, the West End and East End outlets, and the Tolna Coulee control structure. He reviewed lake history, outlet capacities, sulfate and downstream flow limits, and explained that the control structure is intended to prevent a catastrophic uncontrolled release by slowing erosion and head cutting. Members asked about water quality trends, the length of the downstream flow constraint, and whether the Tolna Coulee area had been studied for possible natural overflow or silt buildup. The discussion emphasized ongoing flooding concerns, mitigation for affected landowners, and the need to balance outlet operations with downstream water quality and infrastructure protection.

Transcript Highlights:

• So that TOR claim that TOR claim act.
• </c> governed by the TOR Claim Act. governed by the TOR Claim Act.
• </c> can be governed by the TOR Claim Act. can be governed by the TOR Claim Act.
• </c><00:20:43.440><c> So</c> claims act. So claims act.
• </c> Claims Act. Claims Act.

Keywords: Judiciary, Division A - Room 216, 29 January, 2026; 3:00 PM, 925, all

Transcript Highlights:

• Beyond cleaning up food sources for rodents, a simultaneous step is banning the use of escars in our
• You have a nice clean table. Thank you. Great. Good afternoon. My name is Michelle Grisenden.
• I have personal experience to support this claim.
• So what is the benefit of cleaning this up? Picking up trash and cleaning up...
• The benefit of cleaning this up is that picking up trash and cleaning up properties reduces pest control

Keywords: 995, all

Summary: The Joint Committee on Environment and Natural Resources held a hybrid hearing on a large slate of bills focused on pesticides, pollinators, rodenticides, mosquito control, invasive species, and local authority over pesticide regulation. Chair Becca Rausch set strict two-minute testimony limits due to the very large number of speakers. Early testimony from Senator Moore and Representative Hawkins strongly supported a bill to restrict second-generation anticoagulant rodenticides, citing harms to wildlife, pets, and public health, and noting that California has already adopted a similar model. Testimony also supported a Lowell home rule petition to allow the city to prohibit or restrict these rodenticides, with local officials describing documented raptor poisonings and municipal efforts to phase out use on city property. A major portion of the hearing focused on pollinator protection and neonicotinoid-treated seeds. Witnesses from environmental groups, conservation organizations, academics, and beekeepers argued that neonics harm bees and other beneficial insects, contaminate soil and water, and provide little or no economic benefit in most corn and soybean fields. Several speakers pointed to New York, Vermont, and Quebec as models for restricting treated seeds, and one panel cited research showing only a small percentage of fields benefit economically from the treatments. Support was also voiced for a bill establishing an ecologically based mosquito management program, with advocates criticizing aerial and truck spraying and urging non-chemical, locally tailored approaches. Other testimony supported bills to reform the pesticide board and pesticide regulation process, to give vulnerable municipalities more local control over pesticide use, to protect schoolchildren from pesticides on school grounds, and to respond to invasive species through a centralized state office, coordinator, strategic plan, and trust fund. Many speakers, including representatives from Mass Audubon, MSPCA, the Xerces Society, the Sierra Club, watershed groups, and local wildlife rehabilitators, described impacts on hawks, owls, pets, fish, and broader ecosystems. No votes were taken during the hearing, and committee members generally asked few questions, with the hearing remaining in testimony mode throughout.

Transcript Highlights:

• SB 1064, Clean Trucks Testing. The motion is do pass. We will substitute the roll call from SB 894.
• SB 1146, Advertisement Claims Health Related Products. The motion is do pass. Roll call vote.
• SB 1049, Health Claims Reimbursement. The motion is due pass.
• The motion is due pass as amended per author to clarify license classification and date of claims.
• The motion is due pass as amended per author to clarify license classification and date of claims.

Keywords: 987, senate, all

Transcript Highlights:

• Under one section of the Clean Air Act, which talks about transport emissions, it basically left it to
• The Clean Air Act, just as his predecessor took the opinion contrary to it.
• They created the Clean Air Act; they created the EPA.
• In the course of it, They created the Clean Air Act; they created the EPA.
• it asks Congress to weaken the EPA's authority based on claims that conflict with established science

Summary: The Senate Natural Resources Committee approved its January 13, 2026 minutes and held over Senate Bills 1041 and 11676 for further review. The main substantive hearing was on SB 1197, which would let owners of irrigation grandfather rights in subsequent active management areas sell, lease, or transfer the associated water duty within the same AMA, including for non-irrigated acreage. The sponsor said the bill was intended to help wineries and other farmers in the Willcox and Douglas areas adjust field layouts and expand within existing water limits. Testimony was mixed: the Sierra Club and Rural Arizona Action opposed the bill, warning it could increase groundwater pumping without requiring reductions or tying transfers to AMA management goals, while the City of Willcox and ADWR were neutral but asked for clearer safeguards and statutory guardrails. The committee passed SB 1197 on a 4-3 vote, with one member not voting. The committee then heard and passed SB 1198, which continues the Arizona Beef Council for eight years until July 1, 2034, and SB 1199, which continues the Arizona State Veterinary Examining Board for eight years until July 1, 2034. Both measures received unanimous or near-unanimous support, with members noting the importance of the beef industry and concerns about the shortage of rural and large-animal veterinarians. Finally, the committee considered SCM 1004, a memorial urging Congress to clarify and limit the EPA’s powers and address what the sponsor described as regulatory overreach. Supporters framed it as a call for Congress to fix unclear federal law, while opponents argued it would weaken science-based environmental protections and ignore climate and air-quality concerns. The memorial was approved on a 4-3 vote, and the committee then adjourned.

Transcript Highlights:

• Trent Lang, president of the California Clean Money Campaign.
• Trent Lang, California Clean Money Campaign. We haven't taken a position on S.J.R. 18 yet.
• Dora Rose, League of Women Voters of California, we have similar concerns to California Clean Money.
• Trent Lang, California Clean Money Campaign, strong support. Good morning. Good morning.
• Trent Lang, California Clean Money Campaign, in strong support.

Keywords: 988, house, all

Transcript Highlights:

• And there must be evidence and documentation to back up the claims that many of the folks on the edges
• And one of our member cities is a member of the Clean Power Alliance, which is a joint powers authority
• And one of our member cities is a member of the Clean Power Alliance, which is a joint powers authority
• And so we're hoping that with the Clean Power Alliance... ...board member helping make these kinds of
• Good morning, Sophia Kwatch on behalf of San Jose Clean Energy in support, and a letter is incoming.

Keywords: 987, senate, all

Summary: The Senate Committee on Local Government heard six bills. SB 828 by Senator Cabaldon would require fireworks license applicants to prove they have local storage and land-use permits and would require state-local notification when licenses are denied or revoked, prompted by the Asparto fireworks explosion and concerns about illegal fireworks storage. Fire officials, counties, and fireworks industry representatives spoke in support or with limited concerns; there was no opposition, and the bill passed 7-0 to Appropriations. SB 799 by Senator Allen would revise the South Bay Regional Housing Trust’s governing rules, including more flexibility on board leadership and allowing non-elected alternates in some cases. Supporters said the changes would help the new housing trust function more effectively; some members raised accountability concerns about non-elected alternates handling public funds. The bill passed 7-0 to the Senate Floor. SB 762 by Senator Arreguín would authorize Hercules to ask voters about a local sales tax increase of up to 1% to fund services and infrastructure. Supporters said the city needs more revenue, while one senator cautioned about how such measures are presented to voters; the bill passed 4-2 to the Senate Floor. SB 722 by Senator Wahab would add protections for mobile home residents from displacement tied to SB 79-related development, with strong support from residents, housing advocates, and local governments and no opposition. The committee approved it 7-0 to Appropriations. SB 222 by Senator Wiener would streamline permitting for heat pump water heaters and HVAC systems, with supporters arguing it would reduce costs, speed adoption, and help meet climate goals, while cities, counties, and HOA groups objected to state preemption, fee caps, liability, and local control concerns. It passed 4-1 to Appropriations. SB 677, also by Senator Wiener, made technical cleanup changes to SB 79’s transit-oriented development rules; housing groups supported it, but local government and transit agencies warned the definition changes could expand SB 79’s reach and complicate mapping and implementation. The bill passed 5-2 to Appropriations. At the end of the hearing, the chair announced the committee had completed its agenda and adjourned.

Transcript Highlights:

• We have 110 miles of roads and 1.2 million square feet of rentable facilities that we clean.
• So keep your truck bed clean and the road safer.
• The total cost to taxpayers to clean up and prevent litter in Louisiana each year? $91.4 million.
• The total cost to taxpayers to clean up and prevent litter in Louisiana each year? $91.4 million.
• Britain claimed land along the east coast of North America, but France claimed Louisiana, a vast amount

Keywords: 974, senate, all

Summary: The Louisiana Commission on Civic Education met with quorum, approved the minutes from its previous meeting, and took several action items related to the Legislative Youth Advisory Council (LIAC). The commission unanimously approved the 2026-27 LIAC membership slate after reviewing recommendations from the selection committee, and it also approved the council’s budget and mileage reimbursement guidelines, noting the only change was an updated IRS mileage rate. Members thanked the legislature for continuing to fund LIAC after earlier years when it relied on outside donations. The meeting featured presentations on civic education resources and America 250 programming. Brandon Burris, representing the Lieutenant Governor’s office, highlighted Louisiana state parks, the Checkout Louisiana library backpack programs for parks and museums, Keep Louisiana Beautiful’s anti-litter campaign, and Homework Louisiana. Liam Julian of the Sandra Day O’Connor Institute discussed national civics education trends, teacher discomfort with controversial topics, and the institute’s teacher training, student camps, debate programs, and civics app. Louisiana Public Broadcasting’s Katie Stark and Nancy Torren presented America 250-related materials, including a PBS Kids feature on a Louisiana child and LPB’s “Louisiana’s Hidden History” videos and teacher resources on Bernardo de Galvez and Spanish Louisiana. LIAC members then reported on their work, including school safety efforts, digital service-hour tracking, AP self-study access, minor work permits, AI-generated harassment concerns, and local civic engagement projects. Peggy Cotonia of the Louisiana Center for Law and Civic Education reported 87 Law Day presentations and 287 total Law Day and Constitution Day presentations reaching about 9,400 students, along with updates on awards and a shortened but still free summer institute for teachers. Barry Irwin reported that legislation to clean up outdated commission membership and quorum language had passed the House and been heard in Senate Education, moving toward final passage. The commission adjourned after no further business.

Transcript Highlights:

• from renewable generators who don't claim their renewable energy certificates.
• </c> utilities are able to claim utilities are able to claim the the the renewable<00:03:42.720><c> energy
• </c> renewable generators who don't claim renewable generators who don't claim their<00:03:53.840><c>
• I'm Sam Evans Brown, executive director of Clean Energy New Hampshire.
• We've been Clean Energy New Hampshire.

Keywords: 928, house, all

Summary: The committee first took up House Bill 219, which would revise the renewable portfolio standard by changing several class definitions, eliminating Class 2, lowering the utility obligation for Class 1 thermal renewable energy certificates from 2.2% to 1.7%, and adjusting alternative compliance payments. Representative Vose said the bill would save ratepayers an estimated $5.7 million annually, arguing that Class 2 is already saturated and that the changes would not materially affect renewable energy development. Members questioned the fiscal impact, with an amended fiscal note cited as showing a $1.2 million reduction in general fund revenue, and some members raised concerns that the bill could weaken one of the remaining incentives for renewable investment. The committee also reviewed the bill’s history, including that it had been added to HB 2 and then removed in conference committee. No vote was taken in the work session. The committee then heard House Bill 164, concerning local records retention and the creation of a local records manager position. Secretary of State David Scanlan testified that the position has existed in statute for years but has never been funded, and said the need has grown as records management has become more digital and ADA accessibility has become more important. He described the bill as a way to help towns preserve and digitize records, especially for smaller communities with limited resources, while keeping records locally when possible. Members asked about the fiscal note, the potential cost of a public website and storage system, and whether the state could start by funding the position alone; the secretary said the staffing cost estimate remained accurate but that storage costs could rise over time. Several members expressed support and suggested further discussion with the Department of Information or other agencies. The work session was then closed without action. Finally, the committee opened House Bill 365, which would provide proof of U.S. citizenship assistance for indigent voters. Secretary Scanlan said the bill is intended to help voters comply with the new voter registration documentation requirements by allowing the state to verify eligibility through federal, private, and other state databases, and by providing vouchers to cover the cost of obtaining documents such as birth certificates. He compared the proposal to the earlier voter ID law, which he said was successfully implemented with accommodations for voters lacking acceptable ID. Members asked how “indigent” would be defined and how the process would work for out-of-state-born applicants; the secretary said indigency would likely be based on a voter’s statement of inability to pay and that the state would help identify where to obtain records and, if necessary, verify them through outside databases. The discussion continued as the transcript ended, with no vote recorded.

Transcript Highlights:

• to</c><00:05:22.440><c> breathe</c> to have clean water clean air to breathe to have clean water clean
• Hearing none. clean environment is much more important clean environment is much more important than<
• </c><00:10:26.040><c> air</c> ensure people's rights to clean air ensure people's rights to clean air
• air and just, for instance, clean air or clean water, because we have it in statute?
• What is theoretically clean air?

Keywords: 912, senate, all

Summary: The Agriculture and Environment hearing on January 27, 2025, took up multiple measures, beginning with a proposed constitutional amendment, HB 559, to recognize a right to clean water and air, a healthful environment, climate, native ecosystems, and beaches. The Attorney General’s Office testified with concerns that the amendment’s broad language could create challenges for future legislatures and environmental enforcement, while the Climate Commission and DLNR supported it. Environmental and advocacy groups, including Climate Protectors Hawaii, 350 Hawaii, Greenpeace Hawaii, and others, strongly supported the measure, arguing it would strengthen decision-making and protect Hawaii’s natural resources. Committee members raised questions about how the amendment would interact with existing constitutional protections and recent litigation, and the AG’s office said the proposal could lead to broad judicial interpretation and possible liability issues. The hearing then moved on without a recorded vote on this bill. The committee next heard SB 552, which would establish a healthy soils program in the Department of Agriculture and require annual reporting and funding. The Climate Change Commission supported the bill, and the Department of Agriculture said it stood on its submitted testimony but noted existing commissions and the greenhouse gas sequestration task force already address similar objectives, suggesting SB 552 may duplicate current efforts. Agricultural and environmental advocates, including the Hawaii Farmers Union, Hawaii Farm Bureau, and others, supported the concept of a consolidated healthy soils program, saying it would better organize existing efforts, improve access for producers, and support conservation practices. The Agribusiness Development Corporation said it would support either DOA or ADC administering the program, and committee discussion focused on implementation, program overlap, and whether the bill should better integrate existing compost reimbursement and related efforts. The final measure discussed in the excerpt was SB 678, which would create an Agricultural Development Food Security Special Fund, dedicate a portion of the environmental response, energy, and food security tax to it, and appropriate funds equal to 3% of the state budget for agriculture. The Department of Agriculture strongly supported the bill, saying the funding would align with its goals and help support farmers and ranchers. The Tax Foundation of Hawaii and the Department of Budget and Finance raised concerns that the proposed special fund may not meet statutory criteria. Farm and industry groups generally supported the measure but suggested changes, including adding uses related to local food sourcing, distribution, and biosecurity. Committee members questioned the scale of the appropriation, noting it could amount to roughly $250 million and a major increase in DOA’s budget, and discussed whether the department could realistically implement such a large program. The hearing ended with testimony counts noted for the measures heard, and the chair indicated the committee would reconvene later for any unfinished business.

Transcript Highlights:

• The EI/DBI providers are subject to our enhanced prepayment review process for fee-for-service claims
• And I think the nonpartisan staff here at the Legislature would agree that the teams worked to clean
• So in that process, that would also point to the idea that having this in statute versus just clean up
• Representative Curran. just clean up in rule in 24 months, time would be the the stronger way to go,
• But as a As a compliance officer, I know when people report claims they can perceive things that are

Keywords: 1183, house

Transcript Highlights:

• 422,200 claims of the marriage credit.
• 422,200 claims of the marriage credit.
• </c> claims for the marriage credit in 2021. claims for the marriage credit in 2021.
• Based on the claims for the residential clean energy credit at the federal level, the LBO estimates that
• Based on the claims for the residential clean energy credit at the federal level, the LBO estimates that

Keywords: 1187, senate, all

Transcript Highlights:

• Okay, this bill is clean up on aisle three.
• If an insurance carrier makes a determination on a presented claim and they have a right to review claims
• It's, um, handling or adjusting claims.
• It's, um, handling or adjusting claims.
• </c> I I think someone who is a claims I I think someone who is a claims adjuster,<03:47:29.600><c> for

Keywords: 1189, house, all

Transcript Highlights:

• Some of them are not, and it's about cleaning up the confusion and... ...with the sale of tangible goods
• Some of them are not, and it's about cleaning up the confusion and simplifying things for businesses.
• So if it was a five-year tax credit, an entity would maybe only have one to two years to claim it.
• My name is Mahamostafavi, and I respectfully ask that you help us keep clean energy jobs in our state
• My name is Mahamostafavi and I respectfully ask that you help us keep clean energy jobs in our state

Keywords: 988, house, all

Transcript Highlights:

• doing so, this bill will expand access to energy efficiency programs, climate resilience investments, clean
• April Robinson with A Voice for Choice Advocacy, also on behalf of Clean Earth for Kids, California Nurses
• Any ingredient cannot be claimed as CBI if it is on one of those lists.
• It ensures that these ingredients cannot be claimed confidential business information.
• To be clear, anything claimed as confidential business information under those bills must be disclosed

Keywords: 988, house, all

Transcript Highlights:

• Did you claim that Donald Trump declassified all the documents at Mar-a-Lago?
• Mar-a-Lago, did you claim that? In what proceeding?
• Did you make the claim that Donald Trump had declassified?
• Did you make that claim publicly?
• He is refusing the transparency that he claims to adhere to.