Video & Transcript : 'uncertified educators' :

Page 38 of 500
NH

New Hampshire 2026 Regular Session

House Education Funding (03/31/2026)

Education Funding

Transcript Highlights:
  • </c> and for community college um education. and for community college um education.
  • </c><01:05:15.720><c> Um</c> um education on on that. Um um education on on that.
  • </c> for for CTE education. Thank you. for for CTE education. Thank you.
  • </c> Board of Education. They then step in. Board of Education. They then step in.
  • </c> of special education services. of special education services.
Keywords: 1189, house, all
CA
Transcript Highlights:
  • The Career Education Master Plan lays out a blueprint for our colleges, The Education Master Plan lays
  • Thank you. education or county office with an adult education program can apply for the grant.
  • Department of Education? Kimberly Rosenberger, Department of Education.
  • County Office of Education.
  • That's 17078.62 of the Education Code.
Keywords: 988, house, all
HI

Hawaii 2025 Regular Session

EDU Public Hearing 01-31-2025

Education

Transcript Highlights:
  • Education for Teacher Department of Education for Teacher requested<00:01:01.480><c> classroom</c><00
  • education education sorry<00:25:10.000><c> this</c><00:25:10.240><c> establishes</c><00:25:10.880><c
  • </c><00:51:44.839><c> in</c> that the Department of Education in that the Department of Education in
  • the Department of Education.
  • of Education to audit operations and expenditures of the Department of Education.
Keywords: 912, senate, all
MN

Minnesota 2025-2026 Regular Session

Committee on Higher Education - 01/30/25

Higher Education

Transcript Highlights:
  • pursue higher education.
  • </c> their life to access higher education their life to access higher education shouldn't<00:19:54.640
  • </c> dreaming I've also worked to educate dreaming I've also worked to educate staff<00:20:03.799><c>
  • </c> way you talked about your education way you talked about your education because<00:23:10.039><c>
  • </c> to class a shot at focusing on education to class a shot at focusing on education instead<00:30:
Keywords: 1187, senate, all
LA
Transcript Highlights:
  • We work deeply with civics education and education in general, serving on behalf of C.C.
  • I serve on the Education Committee.
  • I’m served with Representative Freiberg on House Education, and I am a lifelong student of civic education
  • education.
  • Department of Education.
Keywords: 974, senate, all
Summary: The Louisiana Commission on Civic Education met with quorum, approved the minutes from its previous meeting, and took several action items related to the Legislative Youth Advisory Council (LIAC). The commission unanimously approved the 2026-27 LIAC membership slate after reviewing recommendations from the selection committee, and it also approved the council’s budget and mileage reimbursement guidelines, noting the only change was an updated IRS mileage rate. Members thanked the legislature for continuing to fund LIAC after earlier years when it relied on outside donations. The meeting featured presentations on civic education resources and America 250 programming. Brandon Burris, representing the Lieutenant Governor’s office, highlighted Louisiana state parks, the Checkout Louisiana library backpack programs for parks and museums, Keep Louisiana Beautiful’s anti-litter campaign, and Homework Louisiana. Liam Julian of the Sandra Day O’Connor Institute discussed national civics education trends, teacher discomfort with controversial topics, and the institute’s teacher training, student camps, debate programs, and civics app. Louisiana Public Broadcasting’s Katie Stark and Nancy Torren presented America 250-related materials, including a PBS Kids feature on a Louisiana child and LPB’s “Louisiana’s Hidden History” videos and teacher resources on Bernardo de Galvez and Spanish Louisiana. LIAC members then reported on their work, including school safety efforts, digital service-hour tracking, AP self-study access, minor work permits, AI-generated harassment concerns, and local civic engagement projects. Peggy Cotonia of the Louisiana Center for Law and Civic Education reported 87 Law Day presentations and 287 total Law Day and Constitution Day presentations reaching about 9,400 students, along with updates on awards and a shortened but still free summer institute for teachers. Barry Irwin reported that legislation to clean up outdated commission membership and quorum language had passed the House and been heard in Senate Education, moving toward final passage. The commission adjourned after no further business.
HI
Transcript Highlights:
  • Welcome to your joint committees on education and higher education.
  • </c> behalf of the Department of Education. behalf of the Department of Education.
  • Um to to the board of education.
  • Welcome back to your joint committees on education and higher education.
  • We are going to um uh education.
Keywords: 910, house, all
Summary: The joint committees on Education and Higher Education first heard HCR 75 and HR 67, which ask the Department of Education and the University of Hawaiʻi to assess criteria for building an educational pipeline and curriculum for advanced manufacturing and cybersecurity. The Department of Education said it would stand on its written testimony, and UH supported the measure, noting existing community college and four-year programs related to the topic. Members asked how DOE promotes cybersecurity opportunities and whether it provides funding; DOE said schools usually connect with partners and its office works with them, but it does not have separate funding for such efforts. UH also explained that some advanced manufacturing concepts may overlap with 3D printing, material sciences, and entrepreneurship, and described P20 as a forum for aligning K-12 and higher education pathways. The committees then recessed the joint hearing and moved to the Education Committee agenda. The committee next heard HCR 46 and HR 39, which would make DOE recreational facilities available to the public during non-peak hours and non-school days. DOE said it already uses facilities agreements with insurance, liability waivers, indemnification, and certificates of insurance to protect schools. The Attorney General opposed the resolutions, warning that unrestricted public use without safeguards could create substantial liability and cost risks for the state. The measure’s introducer said the goal was to help underserved communities that lack access to public recreation spaces, and DOE said it would be open to joint-use arrangements with larger organizations but remained concerned about vandalism and liability. The committee also heard HCR 86 and HR 80 on creating an Aloha Civics working group, with DOE offering comments and Common Cause Hawaiʻi strongly supporting the idea. DOE described a civic learning and engagement task force that met with stakeholders, including UH and the PACE Commission, and produced recommendations such as building partnership inventories, integrating civic learning across grade levels, and aligning the work with DOE’s HA framework and learner outcomes. Common Cause said civic education can be implemented effectively and affordably, citing existing school projects such as ranked-choice voting and classroom constitutions. Later, the committee took up HCR 87 and HR 81, urging an annual Climate Week in public schools. DOE again stood on written comments, while the Climate Change and Health Working Group, Climate Future Forum, a student from Kaimuki High School, and other supporters argued that a dedicated week would ensure consistent climate education, build resilience, and connect climate issues to health, food security, and disaster preparedness. Supporters said existing climate-related opportunities are uneven across schools and that a formal Climate Week would create a more equitable approach. The committee then heard HCR 95 and HR 91 on informing students about changes to gun safety and storage laws; DOE asked for clarification on the measure’s intended outcome, and one individual testified in support. Finally, the committee heard HCR 104 and HR 100 on strengthening farm-to-school initiatives. DOE said it is already working to improve menus, emphasize local products, and meet with distributors to increase local procurement, while the College of Tropical Agriculture and Human Resilience offered food science, nutrition, and extension support. Climate Future Forum, the Hawaii Youth Food Council, and other supporters said farm-to-school efforts are important for student health, local farmers, and food sovereignty, noting that local food procurement in schools remains far below the state’s 30% by 2030 goal. DOE explained it is trying to provide distributors and farmers with more predictable demand and is meeting with distributors to set up next year’s supply chain.
KY

Kentucky 2026 Regular Session

House Standing Committee on Primary and Secondary Education. (1-21-26)

Primary and Secondary Education

Transcript Highlights:
  • </c><00:04:48.000><c> program,</c> entering the teacher education program, entering the teacher education
  • </c> the Kentucky Department of Education. the Kentucky Department of Education.
  • </c><00:23:56.559><c> and</c> should be handling um as educators and should be handling um as educators
  • Truett is um as a special education Rep.
  • </c><00:25:09.279><c> he</c> education services for basic reading. he education services for basic reading
Keywords: 958, all
CA

California 2025-2026 Regular Session

Senate Education Committee Apr 8th, 2026

Education

Transcript Highlights:
  • The lead agency would support local education agencies by developing inclusive career tech education
  • and Workforce Development, Educational Services Division at the Orange County Department of Education
  • , County Office of Education.
  • Department of Education is tasked with enforcing federal civil rights law in education and may request
  • higher education.
Summary: The committee heard several education-related bills. SB 1154 would allow community college districts to use best-value procurement for public works projects over $1 million. The author and community college supporters argued it would give colleges flexibility similar to K-12, UC, and CSU and help avoid delays and costly change orders. Contractors and electrical subcontractors opposed the bill, saying its skilled-and-trained workforce requirement and safety provisions would narrow competition and disadvantage small and nonunion firms. The bill passed the committee on a due-pass vote and was placed on call. SB 1347 would clarify that stock albuterol may be stocked in all public schools, including preschool programs. The author and a physician testified that the bill would remove confusion in existing law and improve access to emergency asthma medication for students. School nurses, respiratory care advocates, and small school districts supported the measure, and there was no opposition. The bill passed unanimously on a due-pass to the floor vote and was placed on call. SB 1222 would create a pilot program to designate a lead county office to help regions struggling with career technical education implementation. Supporters said many students remain disconnected from school and work and that the bill would spread proven regional CTE practices. Some committee members questioned whether another pilot was needed, arguing existing CTE programs need more funding and fewer new structures, while the author and sponsor said the bill would build regional capacity and share successful models. The bill passed to Senate Appropriations and was placed on call. SB 1378 would create a California Excellence in Service Learning Designation Program to recognize schools and districts with strong service-learning programs. Supporters said it would validate existing work and encourage civic engagement, while one member raised concerns about adding more designations and workload for schools. The bill passed as amended to Senate Appropriations and was placed on call. SB 1048 would create a Seal of Climate Literacy for high school students demonstrating climate science knowledge through coursework and hands-on learning. Supporters, including the Department of Education and climate education groups, said it would align students with growing clean-energy careers; some members cautioned against adding more curriculum-related seals and noted equity and implementation concerns. The bill passed to Senate Appropriations and was placed on call. Later, SB 1101, the Higher Education Data Sharing Transparency Act, was presented. It would require CSU, community colleges, independent colleges, and request UC to notify students, faculty, and staff when their personal information is shared with federal agencies such as the Office for Civil Rights, and to limit disclosure to what is legally required. Supporters said recent federal investigations and subpoenas have created fear and a lack of transparency on campuses. Committee discussion focused on subpoena authority, constitutional limits, and whether notice should be required; one member said she would abstain because of legal concerns, while another said the bill would continue to be examined in the next committee. The transcript ends during discussion of SB 1101 before a final vote is recorded.
FL
Transcript Highlights:
  • Again, really focusing on that education workforce... ...education programs.
  • Simply to clarify, you wouldn’t agree that the educational, both the educational institution and the
  • My other education-focused board membership has included the Education Market Association, which was
  • whose members are thought leaders in education.
  • On civic education issues.
Summary: The committee first took up a confirmation for UCF trustee reappointment candidate Mr. Christie, who described his long service on the board, his UCF business-school background, and his focus on strengthening UCF’s financial foundation, workforce alignment, and engineering and technology programs. Members praised his service and asked about UCF’s future direction, including its role in Florida’s space and engineering sectors. He was allowed to leave early for a meeting with the governor. The committee then heard the Higher Education Appropriations budget presentation for fiscal year 2025-26. The chair outlined a proposed $11.5 billion higher education budget emphasizing workforce education, Florida College System operations, career and technical education, the GATE program, nursing education through the Florida Center for Nursing, UF/IFAS agriculture technology, tutoring, autism and neurodevelopment services, student financial aid, and $250 million for state universities through the Board of Governors. Senator Davis asked about line grant flexibility, and the chair said a conforming bill would address details. The committee adopted a motion allowing technical corrections and then adopted the budget proposal as a recommendation to the full Appropriations Committee. The remainder of the meeting focused on confirmations for university boards, especially the University of West Florida, where several nominees were questioned about Title IX compliance, free speech, workforce readiness, military/veteran ties, and prior statements about privatization and higher education. Rebecca Matthews, Rachel Moyah, Ashley Ross, and Adam Kessel each described their backgrounds and goals for UWF; Kessel faced extensive questioning about his past writings on privatization, the GI Bill, and speech suppression, and said he would not recommend privatizing Florida universities and supported veterans’ education benefits. Public testimony on UWF was largely opposed, with speakers arguing the nominees lacked local ties and warning the slate would harm the university and community. The committee also heard from FAMU reappointment nominee Judge Belvin Perry, who emphasized student success, workforce quality, and FAMU’s continued rise, and from UCF nominee Mark Philburn and FSU nominee Peter Jones, both of whom highlighted their professional experience and commitment to student success and prudent stewardship. The meeting extended its time to 6:30 p.m. to continue hearing nominees and public testimony.
MA

Massachusetts 2025-2026 Regular Session

Senate Session (Full Formal with Calendar) Jun 21st, 2026 at 11:00 am

Massachusetts Senate Floor Meeting

Transcript Highlights:
  • our future early education and care educators.
  • for early education and care, but also has an early education and care program right on site.
  • , future educators for early education and care, but also has an early education and care program right
  • No one would dispute the importance of education. No one would dispute higher education.
  • No one would dispute the importance of education. No one would dispute higher education.
Keywords: 995, all
Summary: The Senate took up a higher education capital bond bill, House 4769, and considered a long series of amendments focused largely on campus facilities, housing, and related policy issues. Many amendments were adopted, including funding or project language for MassBay Community College HVAC and window replacement, Massachusetts Maritime Academy, Springfield Technical Community College, Cape Cod Community College nursing/allied health expansion and housing-related land use, Worcester State University and Quinsigamond Community College, Middlesex Community College, Salem State’s Sullivan Building, Roxbury Community College’s Center for Economic and Social Justice, UMass Boston’s Manning College of Nursing and Health Sciences, and several Massachusetts State College Building Authority updates. Some amendments were rejected, including proposals on a sustainable hand hygiene incentive program, unlocking housing on surplus land, a Senator Bill Owen Center designation, Urban College of Boston, and a board membership change. A number of amendments were held or withdrawn during the process. A major debate centered on an amendment by Senator Tarr to dedicate $300 million of surtax revenue to K-12 education, framed as a response to Chapter 70 funding concerns and the need to modernize school aid. Supporters argued that local districts face rising costs and that the state should set aside fair share revenue for school funding and future school building investments. Opponents said the bill was the wrong vehicle and noted the Commonwealth already dedicates substantial surtax revenue to K-12 programs. The amendment was defeated by roll call. Tarr also offered amendments on a safety valve for surtax revenue declines, equity analysis of surtax allocations, bond covenant requirements, and Chapter 62F taxpayer protections; those were not adopted. The Senate also adopted a separate amendment on AP credit policies at public higher education institutions, though the transcript reflects some procedural confusion around that vote. After completing amendments, the Senate ordered the bill to a third reading and then passed it to be engrossed by a recorded vote of 38-0. Senators then adopted several extension orders giving committees additional time to report on pending bills, including Environment and Natural Resources and Municipalities and Regional Government. The chamber also adopted an order to meet again the following Monday at 11 a.m. The session concluded with a unanimous memorial adjournment in honor of Bolton Police Chief Luke Hamburger, followed by a brief statement recognizing Rare Disease Day and the challenges faced by patients seeking diagnosis and treatment.
WA

Washington 2025-2026 Regular Session

Senate Early Learning & K-12 Education Jan 14th, 2026 at 10:30 am

Early Learning & K-12 Education

Transcript Highlights:
  • In Washington State, we want our students to be educated about cultures, educated about history, and
  • And in Washington State, we want our students to be educated, educated about cultures, educated about
  • history, and educated about the importance of all of us, exist educated about history and educated about
  • The only thing you could blame here is the lack of education.
  • Good education can help students who are humane and empathetic.
AR
Transcript Highlights:
  • House, or joint education, will come to order.
  • as career and technical education.
  • student funding for gifted and talented education as well as career and technical education.
  • That local education agency and our state education agency at the department...
  • education agency.
Keywords: 1204, all
ID

Idaho 2026 Regular Session

Agenda Mar 23rd, 2026

Education

Transcript Highlights:
  • Welcome to the Senate Education Committee.
  • and State Department of Education.
  • Welcome to Senate Education. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
  • And so how much of our education, I guess my question, next question would be how much of our education
  • the Institute of Education Sciences, which is the gold star for education research.
Keywords: 989, all
Summary: The Senate Education Committee heard testimony on House Bill 883, which would create an optional flexibility program for high-performing charter schools and traditional school districts. Sponsors said qualifying schools could gain more spending discretion and be exempted from some reporting requirements if they meet academic, financial, and governance criteria. Supporters from the Idaho Charter School Network and American Classical Schools of Idaho said the bill would let schools direct funds to local priorities and reduce redundant compliance work. A district representative opposed the measure, arguing it would create unequal treatment among public schools and conflict with the idea of a common school system. Senators asked about the number of reports being waived, whether federal funding would be affected, why virtual schools were excluded, and how district and charter criteria compare. The committee voted to send HB 883 to the floor with a due pass recommendation. The committee also considered House Joint Memorial 19, which expresses support for disbanding the U.S. Department of Education and shifting responsibilities elsewhere in the federal government. The sponsor argued the department has led to federal overreach and burdensome mandates, while protections for students with disabilities and other federal programs would still need to continue under another agency. Testimony in support came from the Idaho Family Policy Center, which said education authority belongs primarily to the states. Opposition came from Dr. Victoria Young, who argued the memorial misstates the Tenth Amendment and blames the wrong level of government for education problems. Senators raised concerns about uncertainty over where programs like Pell Grants, special education funding, Title I, and school nutrition would be housed, and about possible impacts on the state education budget if federal responsibilities shift. The committee voted to send H.J.M. 19 to the floor with a due pass recommendation, with one senator noting support but reserving the right to change on the floor.
NH

New Hampshire 2025 Regular Session

House Finance (03/31/2025)

Transcript Highlights:
  • effect of funding the items in the education that are left in the Education Trust Fund through...
  • effect of funding the items in the education that are left in the Education Trust Fund through...
  • effect of funding the items in the education that are left in the Education Trust Fund through...
  • effect of funding the items in the education that are left in the Education Trust Fund through...
  • </c> education that are left in the educ education that are left in the educ ation<03:46:45.199><c> trust
Keywords: 928, house, all
Summary: The Finance Committee met to review Division One of a very large budget package, with the chair explaining that the budget was being analyzed in three divisions over multiple days. Members first discussed procedure, including when amendments and line-item votes would be taken, and agreed to proceed with the division’s presentation before questions. Representative Maguire then outlined the division’s approach as a series of tradeoffs to close a large budget gap, emphasizing cuts, some revenue changes, and a focus on overall spending levels as well as individual reductions. The presentation covered a wide range of agencies and policy areas. Major proposed changes included cuts or eliminations to several boards and commissions viewed as costly or duplicative, such as the Housing Appeals Board, Board of Tax and Land Appeals, Human Rights Commission, Commission on Aging, Office of the Child Advocate, and the Personnel Appeals Board, with some functions consolidated into other boards. The division also proposed back-of-the-budget cuts to the Information Technology Department, Judicial Branch, Justice Department, Retirement System, Corrections, and Environmental Services, along with fee increases in several areas. Other notable items included ending marketing for Paid Family Leave, reducing job advertising and tourism promotion, defunding the Arts Council, moving liquor enforcement functions out of the Liquor Commission, and shifting some funds such as the College Savings Commission money to Division Two. Several members questioned specific cuts, especially the elimination of the Council on Aging, the reduction in regional planning commission grants, and the large cut to tourism advertising. Maguire defended the choices as necessary budget tradeoffs, arguing that some programs duplicated work done elsewhere, that regional planning grants were not among the most essential items, and that tourism promotion was a form of spending he viewed skeptically. He also explained that the public defender’s budget was partially restored after a credible claim of a governor’s budget error, and that the committee would continue refining corrections-related cuts because the House was only halfway through the budget process and further changes could still occur in the Senate and conference committee.
MN

Minnesota 2025-2026 Regular Session

Committee on Education Finance - 03/04/25

Education Finance

Transcript Highlights:
  • education education providers<00:27:13.399><c> while</c><00:27:13.679><c> schools</c><00:27:14.200><
  • ECFE, or early childhood family education, is intended to provide education for parents and caregivers
  • </c><00:30:46.600><c> and</c><00:30:46.760><c> it's</c> care and education and it's care and education
  • </c> public education public education requirements<00:36:51.760><c> the</c><00:36:51.960><c> impact<
  • basic education programs.
Keywords: 1187, senate, all
CA

California 2025-2026 Regular Session

Assembly Education Committee Apr 9th, 2025

Education

Transcript Highlights:
  • Delays in implementation of special education support to military children can create a loss of educational
  • Education requirements, and education code pertaining to inclusive school instructional material and
  • , bilingual education, and early education, childhood education, excuse me, as we fully implement the
  • and aspiring educators.
  • Department of Education. The U.S.
Keywords: 988, house, all
LA

Louisiana 2026 Regular Session

Education Apr 14th, 2026

Education

Transcript Highlights:
  • So I just wanted to take a minute to say welcome to House Education. Welcome to House Education.
  • I just disagree that when you're talking about high school education and college education, we're talking
  • We want them educating our children.
  • predates public education.
  • pre- from our meeting that I was in, but religious education in the state predates public education.
Summary: The committee heard several higher education and K-12 bills centered on TOPS, school accountability, and curriculum alignment. It first welcomed University of Louisiana at Lafayette’s new president, Ramesh Kuluru, who spoke about student success, workforce alignment, and the university’s financial recovery. The committee then adopted amendments and reported HR 17 favorably, directing a study of TOPS return on investment with the Board of Regents, Louisiana Works, LED, and the Blanco Public Policy Center. Testimony from business and policy groups supported the study as a way to assess whether state financial aid is producing workforce and retention outcomes. Members then considered HB 385 by Rep. Bamberg, which would require repayment of TOPS awards under certain circumstances when students lose eligibility, with exemptions for hardship and a pathway into LCTCS or career-technical programs. The bill drew strong debate over whether merit scholarships should ever be repaid; opponents argued TOPS is earned for the semester and should only be lost going forward, while supporters emphasized taxpayer accountability. After amendments, the committee narrowly approved the bill by roll call vote, with Chair Schlegel casting the deciding yes to report it favorably as amended. The committee also unanimously reported HB 1058 favorably, which requires the Board of Regents to maintain a uniform data system for state financial assistance; independent colleges and business groups supported the measure as a way to improve accountability and analysis. The committee next heard HB 406 by Speaker Pro Tem Johnson, which asks the Department of Education to study the feasibility of moving oversight of interscholastic athletics to a more accountable model after a legislative study found widespread complaints about the private LHSAA’s transparency and consistency. Supporters said the bill is a cautious step toward reform and a possible 2028–2029 transition, while an LHSAA representative defended current audits and governance and opposed the premise of the bill. Despite objections, the committee reported HB 406 favorably. It then heard HB 787 by Rep. McMakin, as substituted, which would exempt non-public high school students from the TOPS computer science requirement; BESE and the Department of Education opposed the bill, saying it would separate diploma and TOPS requirements and create scheduling confusion, while Catholic school representatives said the requirement conflicts with their theology curriculum. McMakin asked to defer the bill for two weeks. Finally, the committee unanimously reported HB 1059 favorably, which aligns TOPS math requirements with BESE’s integrated math pathways, and began hearing HB 1021 by Rep. Egan on repayment of certain TOPS awards, though the transcript cuts off before that bill was completed.
LA

Louisiana 2026 Regular Session

Education Apr 14th, 2026

Education

Transcript Highlights:
  • I just disagree that when you're talking about high school education and college education, we're talking
  • The chairman of the House Education and the Senate Education nominated people who served on that committee
  • We want them educating our children.
  • predates public education.
  • pre- from our meeting that I was in, but religious education in the state predates public education.
OK

Oklahoma 2026 Regular Session

Education 2ND REVISED Apr 28th, 2026 at 11:30 am

Education

Transcript Highlights:
  • The morning extended education committee will come to order.
  • We obviously have our Secretary of Education here.
  • Growing up here as a state-educated child myself, with two educating parents, I have a real passion for
  • Beller holds certifications in secondary education, special education, and school administration, including
  • And not only educate our students but educate the citizens of the state through our extension offices
Keywords: 914, all
CA
Transcript Highlights:
  • I'd like to welcome everyone to the Assembly Higher Education Committee.
  • on Senate bills by the Assembly Higher Education Committee.
  • in which they are providing online education to that state's students.
  • The motion is due pass as amended to the Education Committee.
  • Don Capki, on behalf of the California Council for Adult Education and the California Adult Education
Summary: The committee heard several higher education bills. It first approved the consent calendar, which included SB 67 and SB 619. The main discussion centered on SB 437, which would direct the CSU system to develop a fair, evidence-based process for verifying whether someone is a descendant of a person enslaved in the United States, as part of the state’s reparations work. Supporters said the bill fills a gap left by the Reparations Task Force and would create a transparent, credible lineage-verification process; opponents argued genealogy methods already exist, the bill would waste money and delay action, and some raised constitutional concerns. The committee took a vote on SB 437, but the roll was left open after the initial tally showed three ayes and three noes. The committee then heard SB 790, which would allow California to join the interstate reciprocity agreement for online postsecondary education. The author and supporters said the bill would improve consumer protections for California students taking out-of-state online courses and help California institutions compete more effectively by reducing the burden of seeking separate state approvals. Opponents, including University of Phoenix and other groups, argued the bill conflicted with the existing reciprocity framework, could exclude some institutions, and might not actually secure California’s entry into the agreement. The committee voted 3-1 to pass SB 790 as amended to the Business and Professions Committee, with the roll left open. The committee also heard SB 391, which would authorize the Community College Chancellor’s Office to charge fees for research partners seeking access to data. Supporters said the office is absorbing significant unfunded workload from data requests and that fees would help recover costs; opponents, including the California Teachers Association community college association, warned the fees could create barriers for faculty and smaller researchers. Members discussed possible exemptions and implementation details. The committee voted 5-1 to pass SB 391 as amended to the Appropriations Committee, with the roll left open. Finally, the committee heard SB 685, a pilot program to provide cost-of-attendance assistance at four CSU campuses for students who experienced homelessness in high school. Supporters said it would help students cover housing, food, and transportation costs and reduce dropout risk; members asked about eligibility and implementation, and the author explained the bill would use McKinney-Vento homelessness designations and target students at risk of “summer melt” and college homelessness.