Video & Transcript Research : 'exceptions'

Page 29 of 423
MN

Minnesota 2025-2026 Regular Session

Committee on Judiciary and Public Safety - Part 2 - 03/19/26

Judiciary and Public Safety

Transcript Highlights:
  • However, Citizens United made that exception.
  • . exception. exception.
  • So, uh, I United made that exception.
  • And the new power grant that the bill proposes is all of that except political spending power.
  • :08.560> gross specific um exception for gross specific um exception for gross negligence<02:46
Keywords: 1187, senate, all
CA
Transcript Highlights:
  • Our office is committed to strengthening and refining this exception to ensure the effectiveness of the
  • Outside of these reasonable exceptions, the California Public Utility Commission would need certification
  • So my bill has many exceptions, like safety enhancement, commodity costs, and modernization.
  • You have put exceptions in there.
  • You have put exceptions in there.
Summary: The committee first heard AB 13, which would restructure the CPUC to increase legislative oversight, add legislative liaisons, require more detailed and timely reporting on rate-setting decisions, and add a public advocate member. The author and supporters argued the bill would improve transparency, accountability, and geographic diversity in CPUC decision-making amid rising utility rates. Witnesses from TURN, San Joaquin County, SDG&E, and former CPUC Commissioner Loretta Lynch offered support or support-in-principle, while no opposition testimony was presented. Members generally praised the bill’s transparency goals, and AB 13 passed 10-0 to Appropriations, with the roll left open for absent members. The committee then adopted the 2025-2026 committee rules and approved three consent items: AB 61, AB 365, and AB 406. The next bill, AB 99, would cap investor-owned utility rate increases above inflation except for specified costs such as safety, modernization, and fuel/commodity costs. The author and supporters, including a representative of the California Senior Legislature, said the bill was needed to protect ratepayers, especially seniors and low-income customers, from repeated rate hikes. Opposition came from utility labor, utilities, the Chamber of Commerce, and others, who argued the bill was too simplistic, could suppress labor costs, and did not account for major cost drivers such as wildfire mitigation, mandates, and net metering. Several members supported moving the bill forward as a starting point on affordability, while others criticized it as overly blunt. AB 99 passed 11-0 to Appropriations, with the roll left open. The hearing then shifted to an informational panel on strategies to reduce California transmission costs. A Public Advocates Office staffer described a growing backlog of approved-but-unbuilt transmission projects, rising transmission access charges, and long project timelines driven largely by utility pre-application and construction periods. Panelists from Net Zero California and consulting firms presented research suggesting that public financing or public-private partnership lease models could reduce transmission costs by lowering financing, tax, and capital costs, with estimated savings of up to 57% and as much as $123 billion over 40 years. PG&E’s representative said the utility is already pursuing federal loan guarantees, grants, and a public-private partnership with Citizens Energy, but warned that state ownership could create tax, wildfire-liability, and governance risks. Members asked about the CPUC’s role, the causes of delays, and whether public financing could complement existing competitive solicitation processes.
WY

Wyoming 2026 Regular Session

House Minerals, Business & Economic Development Committee, February 25, 2026

Minerals, Business & Economic Development

Transcript Highlights:
  • clears throat] Our chief executive [clears throat] exercised his right with his line-item veto, except
  • <00:33:47.440> for through certain exceptions for through certain exceptions for compensation
  • Government entity is going to deal with everything except for... sometimes for them to uphold laws and
  • <00:48:30.319> to government entity for an exception to government entity for an exception
  • For example, the exception that’s written into the bill to go to the governing body is something that
Bills: HB0075, HB0128
MN
Transcript Highlights:
  • All the hospitals are hurting across the state except for probably the capacity if we lose HCMC.
  • All the hospitals are hurting across the state except for probably And that has some federal ties on
  • All the hospitals are hurting across the state except for probably Where it needs to go as opposed to
  • All the hospitals are hurting across the state except for probably is our system is broken.
  • <00:05:31.080> for<00:05:31.200> probably Across the state, except for probably Mayo
Keywords: 1187, senate, all
FL

Florida 2026 4th Special Session

January 29, 2026 - 03:00 PM

Transcript Highlights:
  • bill number two of the day, we have HB 859 by Representatives Chambliss and Tremont, entitled "Exceptional
  • An IEP outlines special instruction, supports, and services an exceptional student needs to succeed in
  • Challenging process, especially if you're dealing with a child with exceptional needs and you're working
  • I know everyone involved truly wants what's best for these exceptional children, but this bill will help
  • My name is Raymond Munoz, and I am an Exceptional Student Education (ESE) student attending Emerald Cove
FL
Transcript Highlights:
  • This amendment provides that the exception to time limitations applies to any offense that is not otherwise
  • When we had reading the analysis, it talks about exceptions to parental consent.
  • were to do something like that related to what we’re talking about here because we explicitly said, except
  • with the exception like we talked about with Senator Harrell, if someone had already been, you know,
  • with the exception like we talked about with Senator Harrell, if someone had already been, you know,
Summary: The Committee on Children, Families, and Elder Affairs considered several bills. SB 590, by Senator Bradley, would toll the statute of limitations for failure to report suspected child abuse by mandatory reporters until the offense is known to law enforcement, with a retroactivity amendment adopted. Supporters said it would help hold mandatory reporters accountable in institutional abuse cases; it was reported favorably. SB 778, by Senator Simon, would update the definition of forensic client so certain individuals with intellectual disabilities or autism whose charges were dismissed for incompetency could be housed in the same secure setting under Chapter 916, reducing duplicative staffing and space needs at APD; it was also reported favorably. The committee then took up SB 560, by Senator Garcia, which streamlines psychotropic medication procedures for children in DCF custody, clarifies when new medical reports are needed, reduces duplicative background checks, and simplifies consent documentation. An amendment removed language expanding who could serve as a qualified evaluator and revised the Road to Independence Program changes to focus only on post-secondary education services and support, extending eligibility ages to 26 while keeping a five-year maximum. Members discussed fiscal impacts and funding sources, and the bill was reported favorably. Finally, the committee heard SB 1010, by Senator Yarbrough, which strengthens enforcement of existing prohibitions on sex-reassignment prescriptions and procedures for minors and adds civil and criminal penalties, along with Attorney General enforcement authority and related parental rights provisions. An amendment clarified that actions could be brought by individuals as well as the Attorney General and that the provisions apply only to minors. The bill drew extensive public testimony both for and against, with supporters emphasizing child protection and accountability and opponents warning about chilling effects on medical care, schools, and parental rights. Senators raised concerns about standing, scope, and impacts on teachers and clinicians, but the bill was ultimately reported favorably on a 5-1 vote, with Senator Sharif voting no.
TX

Texas 89th 2nd C.S.

Transportation Apr 16th, 2025

Transportation

Transcript Highlights:
  • The removal of the exceptions will appropriately codify the admission rule, fully incorporating the long-standing
  • Are we setting up an exception for this class that's not available for the other class? Well, Mr.
  • Are we setting up a set up an exception for this class is not available for the other class?
  • And in 2021, it was amended to deal with exceptions, especially...
  • It was amended to deal with exceptions, to specify navigation district-related things that were part
Summary: The Senate Transportation Committee heard several bills focused on transportation infrastructure, public safety, and local commemorations. SB 2841 would clarify the overweight corridor designation for the Port of Brownsville so all three statutorily approved bridges are treated uniformly for northbound and southbound overweight traffic; the Port of Brownsville testified in support, and the bill was left pending. SB 39 would restore the commercial motor vehicle “admission rule” framework in collision cases; Senator Birdwell explained the committee substitute, and the bill was later reported favorably. The committee also heard and later advanced SB 682, SB 1369, and SB 1422, which rename stretches of highway or a bridge in honor of fallen firefighters and military service members, with no opposition testimony and all left pending before final votes. The committee also heard SB 2366, which would create a grant program for short-line railroad projects through rural rail transportation districts for track, bridge, capacity, and restoration work. Senator Hughes and several witnesses from rural rail districts and rail advocacy groups supported the bill, while TxDOT explained current rail funding is limited and that the bill would be the first such grant program for Class 3 short lines; members discussed that the bill would need a floor amendment because state funds cannot be paid directly to railroads. SB 1013 would expand crosswalk protections under the Lisa Torrey-Smith Act to include certain driveway curb cuts along sidewalks; it was supported by the author and left pending before later being reported favorably. The committee also considered SB 2080, which would modernize port and navigation district rules by easing records and procurement requirements, exempting certain security and cybersecurity discussions from recording, and expanding some operational authority. Port Houston and the Texas Ports Association supported the bill, while the City of Corpus Christi raised concerns that the language could expand port economic-development authority beyond navigation purposes and affect local tax bases; the Port of Galveston also noted concerns about the filed version but supported the bill as presented, and the committee substitute was later reported favorably. SB 2001 would create specialty license plates and related parking/toll benefits for permanently disabled peace officers; SB 2705 would codify registration exemptions for certain farm equipment and some specialty plates. Both were supported by witnesses, adopted with committee substitutes where applicable, and reported favorably. Final votes on the reported bills were largely unanimous or near-unanimous, and the committee recessed after leaving some motions open briefly.
NH

New Hampshire 2025 Regular Session

House Criminal Justice and Public Safety (02/05/2025)

Criminal Justice and Public Safety

Transcript Highlights:
  • My expectation would be yes, get a warrant without any of the other exceptions, right?
  • My expectation would be yes, get a warrant without any of the other exceptions, right?
  • My expectation would be yes, get a warrant without any of the other exceptions, right?
  • My expectation would be yes, get a warrant without any of the other exceptions, right?
  • My expectation would be yes, get a warrant without any of the other exceptions, right?
Keywords: 1189, house, all
NH
Transcript Highlights:
  • as it's right near the death except as it's right near the beginning<00:45:24.040> except<00:
  • support of this bill with the exception support of this bill with the exception of<00:57:43.520>
  • case except case except insolvency<01:37:45.639> that's<01:37:45.880> the<01:37:46.040
  • There are two exceptions.
  • <01:55:05.520> one then then there are two exceptions one then then there are two exceptions
Keywords: 928, house, all
Summary: The committee first heard testimony on House Bill 167, which would add ski, snowboard, and boat wax containing PFAS to the state’s consumer-product restrictions. The sponsor argued the product is already banned in many places, has PFAS-free alternatives, and is used in ways that can directly contaminate water rather than landfills. She cited high PFAS levels in several New Hampshire lakes and said the bill was a simple extension of prior PFAS legislation. A witness also described a personal experience where a liquid ski wax disappeared from the market and later returned, likely because of PFAS concerns. The chair then closed the hearing on HB 167 without a vote. The committee then opened a hearing on House Bill 312, dealing with college athletes’ name, image, and likeness (NIL) rights. Representative Moffett said the bill was modeled on New Jersey law and intended to let student-athletes earn compensation from NIL without losing institutional scholarships, while also requiring licensed representation and setting limits on certain endorsements. He described the measure as proactive because NIL rules are evolving and could create conflicts among schools and future lawsuits. Members questioned whether the bill should apply to two-year institutions, whether it should exclude firearms and weapons, and whether the scholarship protections would cover need-based or academic aid as well as athletic scholarships. Moffett said the scholarship language was intended to protect scholarships generally, but not need-based aid specifically, and he acknowledged discomfort with some of the endorsement restrictions. Public testimony on HB 312 was mixed. One supporter, a former Division III athlete and coach, backed the bill but urged removal of a section allowing institutions or athletic bodies to use an athlete’s NIL without compensation, arguing most New Hampshire athletes do not receive NIL money and should not have to work extra jobs to cover basic expenses. The chair also raised concerns about the bill’s contractual and identity-rights implications, referencing prior committee work on a J.D. Salinger-related identity case and noting the committee had previously declined to get involved in similar contractual disputes. No vote was taken during the hearing.
MN

Minnesota 2025-2026 Regular Session

State Committee Meeting - 2026-03-26

State Government Finance and Policy

Transcript Highlights:
  • that we wouldn't uh are there exceptions that we wouldn't necessarily<00:26:32.960> as<00:26:
  • It also redefines Admin's authority to more narrowly approve exceptions to policy requirements and kind
  • Generally, an exception request would relate to an individual grant, not necessarily the entire program
  • It improves our process around requirement exceptions and narrows that scope.
  • and narrows that requirement exceptions and narrows that scope.<01:26:53.520> Uh<01:26:53.720
AL

Alabama 2026 1st Special Session

Alabama Senate Finance and Taxation General Fund Committee Mar 4th, 2026

Finance and Taxation General Fund

Transcript Highlights:
  • . >> But it makes certain exceptions. For instance, a person may be driving.
  • arrested for a DUI or with a suspended, canceled, or revoked driver's license. >> But it makes certain exceptions
  • arrested for a DUI or with a suspended, canceled, or revoked driver's license. >> But it makes certain exceptions
  • would be nice if these had similarities instead of being totally different. >> But it makes certain exceptions
ND
Transcript Highlights:
  • other states to be considered for licensure here without having to repeat all of the other things, except
  • other states to be considered for licensure here without having to repeat all of the other things, except
  • perhaps in some cases a section on what North Dakota state law might. ...things, except perhaps in some
  • the API, because there are some children who have severe illnesses, or there might need to be an exception
Keywords: 908, all
Summary: The Health Care Task Force reconvened to hear reports from its divisions. The Appropriations Division reviewed a draft bill appropriating $198 million in federal grant funds for the current year and another $198 million for the next grant year, authorizing DHS to transfer funds within its budget, allowing OMB to adjust federal fund authority for related grants, speeding procurement and bulk purchasing, requiring grant recipients to acknowledge the temporary nature of the funding, and mandating periodic reporting. After questions were answered to the division’s satisfaction, the committee voted to forward the appropriations bill draft to Legislative Management. The Policy Division then reviewed four bills. One would require the presidential physical fitness test to be included in high school physical education; another would require physicians to complete one hour of continuing education on nutrition and metabolic health each renewal cycle; a third would add physician assistants to the interstate licensure compact framework; and a fourth would authorize limited pharmacist prescriptive authority and therapeutic substitution. Members generally supported the first three measures and noted that the pharmacist bill had been amended in discussion but was left in its current form so stakeholders could comment before the special session. The division also discussed that all four policy bills were tied to the federal grant funding and that failure to pass them, or changing them in a way that reduced CMS scoring, could reduce or eliminate funding. Department officials confirmed that if any of the bills failed or were altered in a way that lowered the score, the state could lose money and could not make up the points elsewhere. Members raised concerns about the physical fitness bill, including possible exemptions for students with severe illnesses or physical limitations, and noted the need for DPI input. Leadership indicated the special session hearings would likely begin Wednesday morning. The committee then approved a motion for Legislative Council to prepare a committee report for Legislative Management and adjourned, noting the task force may need to remain available during the special session.
HI

Hawaii 2025 Regular Session

Senate Floor Session 01-17-2025 11:30am

Hawaii Senate Floor Meeting

Transcript Highlights:
  • Today is my very much an honor to welcome 50 exceptional, awesome students from Campbell High School
  • in our beautiful community of Ewa Beach. honor to welcome honor to welcome 50<00:03:14.840> exceptional
  • <00:03:15.599> awesome<00:03:16.159> students<00:03:17.080> from 50 exceptional
  • awesome students from 50 exceptional awesome students from Campbell<00:03:17.760> High<00:03:
Keywords: 912, senate, all
AL

Alabama 2026 1st Special Session

Alabama Senate Finance and Taxation Education Committee Mar 4th, 2026

Finance and Taxation Education

Transcript Highlights:
  • "Yeah, we've already given them the exception that they don't have to pay premium tax.
  • that they don't have to pay exception that they don't have to pay premium<00:12:03.040> tax.
  • that you have before you are all copies that you have before you are all the introduced versions except
  • I do have a substitute right that's being distributed right now. public service except service to the
  • public service except service to the federal<00:39:52.079> government.
NH

New Hampshire 2025 Regular Session

Senate Health and Human Services (05/07/2025)

Health and Human Services

Transcript Highlights:
  • And that's not usually done except by a licensed provider.
  • <00:16:49.360> That's except by a a licensed provider.
  • That's except by a a licensed provider.
  • Yeah, I just followed everything except for one piece. Sure. Is that what you're working?
  • everything except for one piece. Sure. everything except for one piece. Sure.
Keywords: 1191, senate, all
TX

Texas 89th Regular

Criminal Justice Apr 15th, 2025

Criminal Justice

Transcript Highlights:
  • This bill seeks to do the same with ATM and point-of-sale skimming, with the exception that TDLR will
  • State law enforcement is flying blind with little exception, but this bill enacted as law will reverse
  • This bill seeks to do the same with ATM and point-of-scale skimming, with the exception that TDLR will
  • State law enforcement is flying in the blind with little exception, but this bill enacted as law will
  • reverse this. enforcement is flying in the blind with little exception, but this bill enacted as law
Summary: The committee heard several criminal justice bills, with testimony largely focused on public safety, court procedures, and local criminal justice administration. SB 2371 would expand mandatory skimmer-reporting requirements from gas pumps to ATMs, point-of-sale systems, and virtual currency kiosks, with the Texas Financial Crimes Intelligence Center saying centralized reporting would improve investigations, preserve evidence, and help identify organized criminal groups. SB 2581 would repeal a special law governing commissary funds in certain large counties; the sponsor and the Sheriff’s Association said it would restore parity with other counties while keeping spending subject to audit and inmate-benefit limits. Both bills were laid out and left pending after testimony, with no public witnesses opposing them at the hearing. The committee also heard SB 330, which would require voter approval before counties over a certain size reduce prosecutor funding, similar to an existing law for law enforcement budgets. Supporters argued prosecutors are essential to public safety and need stable funding, while an opponent from the Texas Civil Rights Project said the bill would restrict local budget flexibility and impose costly elections. SB 663 would remove district judges’ approval role for community supervision and corrections department budgets, replacing it with judge review after TDCJ-CJAD approval; probation officials said the change would reduce delays and confusion without reducing judicial oversight. SB 1020 would require more immediate sharing of ankle-monitor violation information and clarify that such records are not judicial work product; the Harris County DA’s office and Crime Stoppers supported it, citing inconsistent local practices and delays that can hinder prosecutions. The committee then took up SB 1164 on emergency detention and court-ordered mental health services. The bill, from the Texas Judicial Commission on Mental Health, would update emergency detention forms, clarify officer duties, allow filings in the county where a person is apprehended or located, and add a factor related to a person’s inability to recognize symptoms or appreciate treatment risks. Supporters included family members, law enforcement, and mental health and judicial witnesses who described cases where earlier intervention might have prevented tragedy; opponents warned the broader language could be misused and emphasized due process and the need for dangerousness to remain the standard. SB 2111 on indigent defense would expand access to counsel at first hearings, strengthen managed assigned counsel programs, create internships and fellowships, and adjust other defense-related procedures; the Texas Indigent Defense Commission and county defense program leaders supported it, while the committee substitute removed some provisions to reduce fiscal impact. Finally, SB 2383 would let recently retired DPS officers return to work in limited roles to help address staffing shortages, and SB 2797 would create reciprocal discovery requirements for criminal cases; prosecutors and some committee members said it would reduce trial surprise and improve truth-seeking, while others questioned whether the bill fully matched the state’s disclosure obligations and whether it could burden defense rights. Several bills were left pending after testimony, and the committee established a quorum later in the hearing.
HI

Hawaii 2026 Regular Session

AEN-WLA, AEN Public Hearings 02-11-2026

Agriculture and Environment

Transcript Highlights:
  • Establishes base selection criteria for exceptional trees.
  • Requires the county arborous advisory committees to have at least six members, adopt new exceptional
  • selection criteria for exceptional selection criteria for exceptional trees.<00:09:25.440> Establishes
  • I just want to add that exceptional trees may be beautiful, but trees are not beautification.
  • Exceptional trees may be beautiful, but trees are not beautification.
Summary: The committee heard several measures related to agriculture, invasive species control, trees, reef protection, and land use. SP 2489 would require Department of Agriculture and Biosecurity leases to include access, invasive-species control, and termination provisions; DAB and DLNR supported it, as did several outside groups, while the Hawaii Farm Bureau and Hawaii Cattlemen’s Council raised concerns about notice, cooperation with lessees, and placing penalties on leaseholders for preexisting infestations. The chair noted six testifiers in support, one opposed, and three with comments. SP 2310 would appropriate funds to remove overgrown vegetation from the Kohola stream. DAB supported the bill but explained that the work already completed by its contractor stopped at a DOT boundary, and that the affected parcel appears to be a DOT highway segment on ceded lands; the committee discussed whether the appropriation should instead go to DOT. SP 2372, on exceptional and significant trees, received support from DNR and Outdoor Circle, with testimony describing trees as critical infrastructure and suggesting technical amendments to committee membership and the process for recommending trees to county councils. SP 2426, which would authorize DNR to contract with private parties to maintain sunscreen dispensers at state beaches and promote mineral-based sunscreen as reef-protective, drew support from DNR and reef advocates, while another witness questioned the science behind claims about mineral versus chemical sunscreens and urged broader environmental solutions. SP 2334 would impose a land conversion fee on agricultural land converted to other uses, create a fee fund for programs including healthy soils, and require state agricultural lands to use a conservation metric. DAB offered comments, and testimony from climate and farm groups generally supported the conservation goals but questioned references to programs not yet in place and objected to language excluding solar and wind uses, with one witness urging that agri-voltaics remain allowed. SP 2925, concerning coconut trees, would recognize them as food, water, and cultural resources, require signage for landscape palms, set labeling standards, and create a tax credit for naturally managed consumable coconut trees. DAB shifted from opposition to comments, DNR supported, and testimony from cultural and subsistence advocates strongly backed the bill as a response to coconut rhinoceros beetle impacts; committee questions focused on enforcement of signage, inspection resources, and the proposed tax credit.
MN

Minnesota 2025 1st Special Session

House Human Services Finance and Policy Committee 1/16/25

Human Services Finance and Policy

Transcript Highlights:
  • that<00:12:24.639> again<00:12:25.000> relates<00:12:25.720> primarily exceptions
  • that again relates primarily exceptions that again relates primarily to<00:12:26.600> that<00
  • > appropriation never had a general fund appropriation never had a general fund appropriation except
  • 15.720> when<00:24:15.919> some<00:24:16.120> money<00:24:16.440> was except
  • in fiscal 23 when some money was except in fiscal 23 when some money was appropriated<00:24:17.320><
Keywords: 1183, house
Summary: The committee met for an introductory overview of its jurisdiction and staff roles. Nonpartisan House Research and House Fiscal staff explained that they draft bills and amendments, prepare bill summaries and background research, answer legal and fiscal questions, and help track revenue and budget effects. They also distributed a Budget Overview Brief intended to condense the larger budget materials into a more usable format for members. Staff then walked through the Human Services budget and the committee’s areas of responsibility. They described the department structure, noting that DHS oversees administration, compliance, rulemaking, and county support, and that the overall Human Services budget is large, with medical assistance as the dominant program. They also explained recent and upcoming reorganizations: many children and family-related functions are moving to the new Department of Children, Youth, and Families, Direct Care and Treatment is becoming its own agency, and some homelessness-related functions remain at DHS. Staff reviewed how the budget is organized by program and budget activity, the difference between direct appropriations and standing appropriations, and how forecasted programs and “tails” work in the budget process. The presentation also covered Medicaid financing and long-term care. Staff explained the federal-state FMAP match, including Minnesota’s current 51.16% federal match for most Medicaid spending, the CHIP match, and the 90% federal share for the expansion population. For long-term care, they outlined Medical Assistance services for elderly and disabled people, state-funded long-term care supports, and Board on Aging programs. They highlighted the personal care assistance program’s phaseout and replacement by Community First Services and Supports, and reviewed the five home- and community-based waivers. Members asked one question about refugee resettlement funding, specifically whether it covers flights; staff said they would need to follow up on the exact use of the federal funds. No bills were heard, and no formal votes or other committee actions were taken during this meeting.
NH

New Hampshire 2026 Regular Session

House Education Funding (01/15/2026)

Education Funding

Transcript Highlights:
  • They can agree with exceptions, meaning they agree with parts and not with other parts, in which case
  • they have to articulate what their exceptions are, and the district has some opportunities depending
  • on what the exceptions are to either move forward with the parts they do agree with and then figure
  • They can agree with exceptions, meaning they agree with parts and not with other parts, in which case
  • c> agree<00:58:51.760> with exceptions, meaning they agree with exceptions, meaning they agree
Keywords: 1189, house, all
NH

New Hampshire 2025 Regular Session

House Judiciary (03/05/2025)

Transcript Highlights:
  • There's an exception for 911 calls.
  • there's a huge carve out of exceptions there's a huge carve out of exceptions where<03:16:44.199
  • And the exceptions are very broad.
  • > broad<03:20:30.359> uh the exceptions are very broad uh the exceptions are very broad
  • <03:25:20.520> in<03:25:21.080> uh exception in uh exception in uh 195<03:25:23.160>
Keywords: 928, house, all
Summary: The House Judiciary Committee met to hear House Bill 520, which would authorize the Department of Education to issue subpoenas in investigations and hearings involving the code of conduct for New Hampshire educators. Representative Lynn, the bill sponsor, said the measure was intended to give the department standard subpoena power during investigations and in later adjudicatory proceedings, with a process for challenging overbroad subpoenas. He argued that agencies with investigative and hearing authority should also have the power to compel witnesses and documents, and said the bill was narrowed from an earlier broader draft to focus on teacher credentialing and address concerns about scope. Members raised several concerns about whether the department already has enough authority, whether the Attorney General could handle subpoenas instead, and whether the bill creates an imbalance by giving subpoena power mainly to the investigating side. Representative Burroughs said she did not feel she had enough information and was uncomfortable with the bill, especially regarding who bears subpoena costs. Representative Biron questioned the trial analogy and whether both sides truly have equal subpoena rights. Lynn responded that the investigative stage is like a grand jury process, where only the investigating body subpoenas witnesses, while the adjudicatory stage allows both sides to seek subpoenas through the hearing officer. Other questions focused on the bill’s scope. Representative Andreos asked what investigative authority the Department of Education already has, and Representative Organ questioned why the bill is limited to educators rather than also covering vendors, charter school boards, or the EFA scholarship organization. Lynn said the limitation to educators was deliberate, because earlier broader versions drew objections for being too expansive. Representative Tur asked whether the Attorney General could already handle such matters, and Lynn said that while the AG might be able to pursue some investigations or court subpoenas, agencies should be able to conduct their own internal investigations. No vote or final action was taken in the portion of the hearing provided.