Video & Transcript Research : 'STEM programming'

Page 26 of 500
HI

Hawaii 2025 Regular Session

HWN Public Hearing 01-28-2025

Hawaiian Affairs

Transcript Highlights:
  • Uh, moving on, I have Johanna Chotam from the ʻŌlelo Hawaiʻi program. Aloha, Chair Richard.
  • Please come up. program<00:04:49.960> ala<00:04:50.400> chair<00:04:50.720> Richard<
  • /c> program ala chair Richard program ala chair Richard CH<00:04:52.919> ala<00:04:53.919>
  • The problem stems from the process, from the boards and commissions, when you apply to the state historic
  • role in overseeing the program role in overseeing the program potentially<01:13:02.600> limiting
Keywords: 912, senate, all
Summary: The Committee on Hawaiian Affairs opened its first meeting of the 33rd Legislature with housekeeping announcements, including live streaming, a two-minute testimony limit, and notice that the committee would reconvene later if technical problems forced an early adjournment. Members introduced themselves, and the chair explained that written testimony was already on file and that public testimony would be taken measure by measure. On SB 109, which concerns the relationship between Hawaiian and English versions of state laws, the Department of the Attorney General raised concerns that broadly allowing the Hawaiian text to supersede English could create ambiguity, and recommended narrowing the bill to laws originally drafted in Hawaiian that were never later amended in English. The Judiciary supported the bill, saying it reinforces Hawaiian as an official language, while OHA and several individuals also supported it. Testimony in support emphasized the importance of honoring Hawaiian language and preventing it from being treated as secondary. The committee then heard SB 268 on burial councils and SB 269 on the OHA budget. SB 268 drew strong support from OHA-related witnesses and many members of the public, who said burial council quorum problems and delays have hindered protection of iwi kupuna; one Moka representative opposed the bill, arguing the island had not been adequately consulted and that the real issue was the state process rather than council size. SB 269 received support from OHA and public testifiers who said OHA should be strengthened and better funded to serve Native Hawaiian needs. The committee also heard SB 624 relating to Prince Jonah Kūhiō, with DHHL and OHA supporting the measure to display portraits of Prince Kūhiō in public buildings; testifiers said the bill would promote cultural pride, education, and recognition of his legacy. No votes were taken during the portion of the meeting provided.
MN
Transcript Highlights:
  • carriers<00:06:38.039> and<00:06:38.160> so They were very optimistic that a stem
  • During Gavin's stem cell transplant, Shann and I lived in a hotel, taking turns staying in his hospital
  • Monona as super gab day<00:08:18.960> during<00:08:19.240> Gavin's<00:08:19.599> stem
  • <00:08:19.840> cell<00:08:20.120> transplant day during Gavin's stem cell transplant
  • day during Gavin's stem cell transplant shann<00:08:21.120> and<00:08:21.240> I<00:08:
Keywords: 1187, senate, all
AL

Alabama 2025 Regular Session

Alabama House Feb 5th, 2025

Alabama House Floor Meeting

Transcript Highlights:
  • Please stop by for a biscuit and a STEM demo from 10:00 a.m. to...
  • A STEM demo will take place from 10:00 a.m. to 12:00 p.m. on the 6th floor, in rooms 602 and 603.
Keywords: 1136, house, all
MN

Minnesota 2025-2026 Regular Session

Committee on Jobs and Economic Development - 03/16/26

Jobs and Economic Development

Transcript Highlights:
  • staff,<00:37:40.320> 90<00:37:40.720> program program areas, 30 staff, 90 program
  • So the medtech soldering program that is a new program that we're launching.
  • So the medtech soldering program that is a new program that we're launching.
  • So the medtech soldering program that is a new program that we're launching.
  • So the medtech soldering program that is a new program that we're launching.
Keywords: 1187, senate, all
NH

New Hampshire 2025 Regular Session

House Session (05/08/2025)

New Hampshire House Floor Meeting

Transcript Highlights:
  • <01:41:20.719> now division is looking into the program now division is looking into the program
  • If I know the EFA program is Speaker.
  • This program is being year's session.
  • lifelong skills in STEM and teamwork. lifelong skills in STEM and teamwork.
  • , you're into programming, mechanics, you're into programming, mechanics, business,<03:11:36.560>
Keywords: 1189, house, all
MN

Minnesota 2025-2026 Regular Session

Committee on Higher Education - 04/07/26

Higher Education

Transcript Highlights:
  • North Star Promise program really is. North Star Promise program really is.
  • This is absolutely necessary for our STEM-focused academic programs.
  • This is absolutely necessary for our STEM-focused academic programs.
  • This is absolutely necessary for our STEM-focused academic programs.
  • This is absolutely necessary for our STEM-focused academic programs.
Keywords: 1187, senate, all
HI
Transcript Highlights:
  • But every union has apprenticeship programs, and to that point I agree with Cliff, and saying that for
  • The real safety crisis stems from thin frontline staffing and a leadership culture of favoritism and
  • <00:47:59.400> from<00:47:59.599> thin<00:47:59.880> Frontline crisis stems
  • Program.
  • Statewide insurance program.
Keywords: 912, senate, all
Summary: The joint committees on Labor and Technology, Transportation, and Culture and the Arts heard testimony on Senate Bill 396 and Senate Bill 47, then later the Labor and Technology committee took up Senate Bill 136 and Senate Bill 1523. SB 396 drew support from the Metropolitan Planning Organization and others, with a question raised about implementation costs; the director said costs would depend on the scope of the benefit package and the transportation mode involved. The committees recommended passing SB 396 with technical amendments and added appropriation language with a blank amount, and the motion was adopted by recorded votes in both committees. SB 47, which would designate the Lunar New Year as a state holiday, received support from the Office of Collective Bargaining and several individuals, including Charlene Chun, who spoke about family traditions and cultural recognition. Members asked about the cost and whether the day would be a paid day off for state employees; the response was that observance would be subject to collective bargaining. The committees moved SB 47 forward with amendments, noting the collective bargaining and cost issues, and adopted the recommendation by vote. In the Labor and Technology committee, SB 136 on the Iron Workers Stabilization Fund drew strong support from iron workers and related supporters, who argued the bill was about safety, training, and keeping dismantling work within the ironworkers’ trade. Several other unions, including operating engineers, carpenters, laborers, and plumbers and fitters, opposed the bill as too broad and potentially infringing on their jurisdiction. The measure was not decided in the portion provided, but members discussed possible amendments and jurisdictional concerns. SB 1523, which would expand private-sector collective bargaining rights under the Hawaii Employment Relations Act to include independent contractors and others under NLRB jurisdiction, received broad labor support, including from IATSE, AFL-CIO, Hawaii Nurses Association, Unite Here Local 5, and many individual testifiers. Supporters framed it as protecting workers’ rights and strengthening labor protections, while the Hawaii Labor Relations Board warned it could significantly increase workload and require more staffing, space, and operating resources; the board estimated the bill could expand its caseload substantially and suggested an appropriation would likely be needed. The committee then moved on to the next measure, SB 1440, before the transcript ended.
FL

Florida 2026 Regular Session

FL House Floor Session - 2026-03-09 (1:00PM Session)

Florida House Floor Meeting

Transcript Highlights:
  • development agency for the purpose of administering a state- or federally funded small business loan program
  • The ought to be a law program where the heart and hustle fit.
  • We graduate over 30,000 students to NCAA sports programs every single year.
  • I can't imagine what the next STEM club is going to look like when some of the engineers in town start
  • sponsoring that STEM club, and that STEM club takes off.
Summary: The House convened with prayer, a moment of silence for former Lee County Judge John Carlin, the Pledge of Allegiance, and recognition of Officer Cody Popple of the FSU Police Department for his actions during the April campus shooting. The Speaker also outlined the final week of session, noting the chamber had passed 253 House bills and 149 Senate bills to date, with budget negotiations still unresolved and the 2026-27 budget not expected to be completed that week. The special order report was adopted, setting the day’s calendar and debate times. The chamber then took up several Senate bills, mostly technical or open-government sunset review measures, and passed them with little or no opposition: SB 100, SB 104, and SB 102 on Florida statutes; SB 7006, SB 7014, SB 7002, SB 7012, SB 7024, SB 7016, SB 7026, SB 7008, SB 7000, and SB 7004 on public-records or meeting exemptions; and SB 7022 on public records related to exams. Members asked questions on a few of these bills, especially the exam-records bill and the military and gaming-related exemptions, but the measures generally advanced without amendment. Votes ranged from unanimous to modest opposition, with SB 7026 passing 106-3 and SB 7022 passing 101-8. The most substantial debate centered on SB 7040, which recreates the emergency preparedness and response trust fund in the Executive Office of the Governor. Rep. Eskamani offered an amendment to let the fund expire, arguing the money had been misused and that the Legislature should retain control over spending; several members supported her position, while others said the fund is needed for rapid disaster response. A strike-all amendment from Rep. Griffiths was adopted instead, adding accountability provisions and expanding the fund to cover man-made emergencies as well as natural disasters. The bill then passed 82-25. The House also passed CS/CS/SB 302 on coastal resiliency, CS/CS/SB 984 on firefighter cancer benefits, CS/SB 474 on military affairs, and SB 488 on Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles issues, with SB 488 still under amendment debate when the transcript ends.
US
Transcript Highlights:
  • Partnering with PRC programs that task and incentivize U.S. faculty members to bypass merit-based hiring
  • This also translates to fewer opportunities domestically and an erosion of STEM talent pipelines.
  • They're here with the STEM fields and the nationalities.
  • And then the foreign aid pause last week, which didn't just affect programs in Latin America, it affected
  • I would hope to see them extended to other programs, including the counter-China programs.
MN
Transcript Highlights:
  • branch, including human resources, finance, legal research, information technology, and statewide program
  • management the Chief Justice of program management the Chief Justice of course<00:04:26.639> leads
  • , court interpreters, mental health examinations in criminal and civil commitment cases, and jury program
  • At the same time, we've seen printing, postage, and other costs strain our jury program budget.
  • At the same time, we've seen printing, postage, and other costs strain our jury program budget.
Keywords: 1183, house
Summary: The House Judiciary Finance and Civil Law Committee heard a presentation from State Court Administrator Jeff Shorba on the Minnesota judicial branch’s 2026-27 budget request. He outlined the courts’ structure and workload, noting 322 judges, about 2,800 staff, roughly 1 million district court cases annually, and a current budget of about $479 million. Shorba emphasized the courts’ constitutional role, the fact that court fines and fees are deposited into the general fund rather than retained by the branch, and recent legislative investments that helped reduce pandemic-era backlogs, improve technology, sustain treatment courts, and raise interpreter and examiner pay. The budget request focused on several areas: a 6% judicial salary increase to address recruitment and retention problems, including a 15% rise in turnover and a 27% drop in applicants since 2020; funding for health care and office lease cost increases; digital accessibility compliance work required by new federal ADA rules; a modernized justice partner access system for court records; higher pay for forensic psychological examiners, whose workload has risen sharply; increased juror compensation from $20 to $100 per day and mileage adjustments; and ongoing funding for interpreters, jury services, and cybersecurity. Shorba said the total request would be a 12% increase over the FY 2026-27 base budget. Members asked follow-up questions about funding for newly launched treatment courts and how those courts are financed after federal grants expire. Shorba said he would provide more detail later and noted the branch generally starts treatment courts with federal funding before seeking state support. Representative Ric also asked about labor negotiations, and Shorba explained that the judicial branch negotiates its own contracts rather than using the executive branch, with three unions involved and many unrepresented employees. No votes or formal actions were taken during the discussion.
TX
Transcript Highlights:
  • Texas A&M established back in 2017 the academic security and counter-exploitation program.
  • And we need progress. programs like this so that we can address those vulnerabilities without breaking
  • , research programs, etc.
  • I don't, I don't track data related to my students or any students in my program.
  • SB 37 treats non-STEM faculty as inferior to STEM faculty, and Enduring the collaboration necessary to
KY
Transcript Highlights:
  • Um these turn into commission programs.
  • And that stems from our constitutional language, not totally statutory language.
  • And that stems from our constitutional language, not totally statutory language.
  • And that stems from our constitutional language, not totally statutory language.
  • And that stems from our constitutional language, not totally statutory language.
Summary: The committee received reports on special purpose governmental entities from the Department for Local Government and the Fire Commission. DLG staff described SPGEs as limited-jurisdiction political subdivisions and reviewed the department’s registry, reporting portal, compliance monitoring, and planned system upgrades such as a two-way message center, automated noncompliance notices, and tracking for new entities and board expirations. They reported that, as of October 10, 2025, 69% of SPGEs were active and discussed compliance data by cycle, fiscal year, and district type. The Fire Commission reported that fire department mergers have reduced the number of departments by 16 since last year, largely because of volunteer staffing shortages, while financial disclosure compliance had risen to 94%. The commission also noted 509 compliance reviews, 19 in-house inquiries, seven referrals to outside agencies, and one recent federal prison sentence in a theft case. Members asked whether DLG advises SPGEs on tax rates; staff said it only performs calculations and the entities set their own rates. Questions to the Fire Commission focused on whether department reductions meant station closures; officials explained that most changes were mergers that keep physical buildings in place while combining personnel and finances to meet minimum staffing requirements. They said the trend is spread across the state but is especially pronounced in rural areas. The Kentucky League of Cities then presented its 2026 legislative agenda. Its priorities included modernizing city revenue options, increasing equity in road funding, fixing tax increment financing issues, addressing transient room tax collection from web-based platforms, strengthening emergency response coordination, clarifying massage parlor regulation preemption, correcting unintended consequences of House Bill 606, improving newspaper publication rules, and modernizing procurement statutes. KLC also said it supports allowing all cities to collect restaurant tax revenue, wants cities to receive a larger share of road funds and EV-related revenues, and seeks state collection and remittance of any future local sales tax to comply with the Streamlined Sales and Use Tax Agreement. Members asked about best-value bidding, road-fund equity, Airbnb tax litigation, EV prevalence, and disaster funding applications; KLC said cities currently must accept the lowest bid, the road split should better reflect city street costs, the Airbnb tax case remains pending, EV data by locality has not been studied, and allowing cities to apply directly for disaster funds would reduce reliance on county officials. No votes or formal actions were taken beyond approving the September meeting minutes.
MA

Massachusetts 2025-2026 Regular Session

Joint Committee on Public Health Jun 21st, 2026 at 10:00 am

Joint Committee on Public Health

Transcript Highlights:
  • Wendy Woodward, Director of the IBC program at MD Anderson Cancer Center.
  • I am the interim program director of the Westfield State University Physician Assistant Program.
  • We are the only public PA program in the Commonwealth.
  • I've been a participant in the Massachusetts PCA program since 2007.
  • There is no public health crisis stemming from complementary.
Keywords: 995, all
Summary: The Joint Committee on Public Health held a hearing to take testimony on a wide range of bills involving professional licensure, clinical practice, and public health-related workforce issues. The chair explained that no votes would be taken at the hearing and that the purpose was to gather public input. Early testimony focused on Marnie’s Law, with supporters describing the bill as a no-cost, preventive measure to require nursing education on inflammatory breast cancer after a family tragedy and arguing it could reduce misdiagnosis and save lives. A major portion of the hearing centered on bills affecting clinical decision-making and licensure compacts. Supporters of the physician ownership/clinical autonomy bills argued they would protect independent practices from corporate interference after the Steward collapse, while supporters of EMS, dental, psychology, physical therapy, and physician assistant compacts said the measures would improve workforce mobility, reduce delays, and expand access to care, especially for rural patients, military families, and telehealth users. Several witnesses emphasized that the compacts would not reduce standards and would strengthen public protection through shared disciplinary databases and streamlined credentialing. There was also testimony on bills to ensure safe medication administration and to protect the independence of complementary and alternative health care practitioners. Nursing representatives urged that only licensed professionals administer medications in hospitals, hospices, and home care settings, warning that delegation to unlicensed staff could endanger patients and nurses’ licenses. A complementary and alternative care witness supported consumer access with mandatory disclosures and limits on reserved medical acts. On the dental compact, witnesses were split: some supported portability and workforce flexibility, while others warned the compact lacked a hands-on skills exam and could weaken Massachusetts’ regulatory authority and patient safety. The hearing concluded with continued testimony on the psychology compact, physical therapy compact, and physician assistant bills, with most speakers favoring expanded interstate practice and reduced administrative barriers.
MS

Mississippi 2026 Regular Session

Appropriations - Room 216, 20 January, 2026; 2:30 PM

Appropriations

Transcript Highlights:
  • Is that a degree program or is that a certificate program? >> Yes.
  • Is that a degree program or is that a certificate program? >> Yes.
  • Is that a degree program or is that a certificate program? >> Yes.
  • These funds allow us to enhance our programs, to expand our programs, and be innovative in the programs
  • That's just the 4-H program in the AD program in our farm and food safety program.
Summary: Mississippi State University officials testified in support of the university’s separately funded agricultural, forestry, and veterinary units, emphasizing their economic impact, research output, and need for continued state support. Keith Cobalt, vice president for the Division of Agriculture, Forestry and Veterinary Medicine, said the division generates a $1.7 billion impact on Mississippi, but warned that state and local funding has not kept pace with federal dollars or inflation. He argued that global competition, especially from China and Brazil, is hurting row crop and forestry producers, and highlighted a Vision 2030 study finding about $10 billion in agricultural and forestry value leaves the state through value-added processing. He also raised concerns about rural depopulation and proposed rural innovation hubs to help retain population and jobs. Nick Frank, dean of the College of Veterinary Medicine, said state appropriations make up about 25% of the college’s operating budget and are needed to support salaries, staffing, and service capacity. He described the college’s education, diagnostic, and clinical missions, including disease surveillance and responses to threats such as avian influenza, screwworm, and equine herpes virus. Frank said the college is expanding facilities with $18 million in 2024 state funding for a new farm animal hospital and cattle handling facility, but still needs additional support for equine and small animal renovations. He also requested support for rural veterinary scholarships and said inflation and salary competition from other schools and private practice are making retention difficult. In response to committee questions, Frank said the college enrolls about 118 to 119 students per class, with roughly 54 to 55 in-state students and tuition of about $29,900 for in-state and $53,000 for out-of-state students. He clarified that the “vet assistants” program is a four-year bachelor’s degree in veterinary medical technology, not a certificate. He also explained that staffing growth has largely been in the hospitals to address clinical shortages and improve care. Dr. Westberger, dean of the College of Forest Resources and director of the Forest and Wildlife Research Center, said Mississippi’s forests support a $19 billion economic impact, 84,000 jobs, and a $4.5 billion payroll, while also providing environmental benefits. He said the college and research center are nationally recognized, including an NSF ranking placing Mississippi State 10th in natural resource conservation research expenditures for a small university. Westberger highlighted research on forest management, pest detection, mass timber, wildlife disease surveillance, and value-added bioproducts, including efforts to attract mills and manufacturing. He said Mississippi has added 10 mills or mill expansions in five years with more than $1.5 billion in investment and over 1,000 high-paying jobs, and noted the college is planning a new mass-timber annex to address capacity and showcase the material. No votes or formal committee actions were taken in the portion provided.
NM

New Mexico 2025 Regular Session

IC - Legislative Health and Human Services Jul 22nd, 2025

Legislative Health & Human Services Committee

Transcript Highlights:
  • The funds were used for various programs, one of which was a respite care program that provided direct
  • There's also a program, the New Mexico Health Service Corps, which is a stipend program.
  • on board with the J-1 visa program.
  • program.
  • They've adapted well with the forest programs and the allied health programs.
NH

New Hampshire 2025 Regular Session

House Committee on Housing (01/14/2025)

Housing

Transcript Highlights:
  • So the $100 million was set up in a program we called the Invest NH program, that launched in the summer
  • But that was a very popular program, and we have run the course on that program.
  • c><00:15:23.399> uh course on that program another one uh course on that program another one uh
  • /c> course that particular program I think course that particular program I think we<00:17:53.799>
  • I worked with all types of HUD programs, including many housing programs.
Keywords: 1189, house, all
NH

New Hampshire 2026 Regular Session

House Health, Human Services and Elderly Affairs (03/04/2026)

Health, Human Services and Elderly Affairs

Transcript Highlights:
  • programs to begin with. programs to begin with.
  • refugee program works. refugee program works.
  • medicinal marijuana program. medicinal marijuana program.
  • the SNAP program. the SNAP program.
  • um a nutrition program. um a nutrition program.
Keywords: 1189, house, all
KY
Transcript Highlights:
  • The STEM Initiative Task Force was also passed in about that time period, and it's my understanding they
  • but they haven't met since 2005<00:18:24.880> uh<00:18:25.559> the<00:18:25.679> stem
  • ><00:18:26.159> initiative<00:18:26.720> task<00:18:27.080> force 2005 uh the stem
  • initiative task force 2005 uh the stem initiative task force was<00:18:27.799> also<00:18:28.240
Keywords: 958, all
Summary: The committee first took up House Bill 276, which would revise the membership of the performance-based funding work group for postsecondary education. Representative Tipton explained that the committee substitute changes the group so the CPE president chairs it as a nonvoting member, all nine university and KCTCS presidents serve as nonvoting advisory members, and the voting members are three House members, three Senate members, the state budget director, and one gubernatorial appointee. He said the goal was to reduce deadlock among institutions and allow legislators to deliberate before meetings. Some members raised concerns that the change shifts influence away from the universities and toward the legislature, but Tipton said he had not heard pushback from the presidents. The committee adopted the substitute and passed HB 276 with an expression of opinion that it should pass with the committee substitute attached; several members voted yes, while Representative Roarx voted no and Representative Stalker passed. The committee then considered House Bill 711, another bill sponsored by Representative Baker and presented by Representative Tipton. Tipton said the measure is a cleanup bill for postsecondary statutes, repealing outdated provisions for groups that have not met in years, including the Strategic Committee on Postsecondary Education, the STEM Initiative Task Force, and local P-16 councils, and removing obsolete language about one-time board appointments. It also strikes the statutory definition of remedial education because Kentucky public postsecondary institutions no longer offer remedial classes, instead using transitional courses with wraparound support that count for credit. A question was raised about whether Senate confirmation requirements for some appointees had been removed in the committee substitute, and Tipton confirmed they had. The committee then passed HB 711 with an expression of opinion that it should pass with the committee substitute attached. After the bills, the committee reviewed administrative regulations from the Council on Postsecondary Education. CPE Senior Vice President and General Counsel Travis Pahl explained that the regulations update the performance funding model for the Kentucky Community and Technical College System to reflect changes made by Senate Bill 191, including a Community Needs Index that reallocates part of an equity adjustment based on regional poverty, unemployment, and labor participation across the 16 colleges. Members were told the committee could ask questions, propose amendments, or find the regulations deficient, but no further action was taken. The meeting then adjourned.
NM
Transcript Highlights:
  • And we make sure it's a voluntary program.
  • It's two basic programs: the GI Bill, which is the oldest scholarship program in the United States, and
  • Part of the deal for Chapter 35, which is our biggest program, is that to receive that program, you have
  • Obviously, the state is offering a variety of different programs. scholarship programs, so the incentive
  • and establishes a partial claim program.
CA
Transcript Highlights:
  • With the implementation of all the COVID-era infrastructure programs and the BEAD program, ideally all
  • With the implementation of all the COVID-air infrastructure programs and the Bede program, ideally all
  • That's the federal government program stemming from the Infrastructure Act, and that is meant to get
  • It was supposed to run alongside of the BEAD program.
  • programs for broadband access.
Summary: The Assembly Communications and Conveyance Committee held an informational hearing on the state of broadband affordability in California. Chair Tasha Berner said the committee was examining how broadband prices, access, and affordability are affecting households, especially after the end of the federal Affordable Connectivity Program and amid concerns about federal resistance to state broadband regulation. She noted the committee’s continued interest in policy options for 2026 and referenced prior legislation, including AB 353, that would have required affordable home internet as a condition of doing business in California. Industry witnesses from U.S. Telecom and CTIA argued that broadband and wireless prices have generally fallen in real terms even as inflation and other household costs have risen, citing competition, infrastructure investment, and faster speeds as the main drivers. They said California’s higher costs are tied to permitting delays, taxes, copper theft, and legacy obligations such as COLR requirements, and they urged the Legislature to preserve market incentives, reduce fees and regulatory burdens, and support infrastructure deployment. They also discussed fixed wireless access, federal BEAD funding, and Universal Service Fund reform, arguing that more entities benefiting from networks, including tech platforms, should contribute to support programs. Consumer and public-interest witnesses presented a different view, saying California still has a serious affordability and adoption problem, especially for low-income households. Sunny McPhee of the California Emerging Technology Fund said broadband adoption has improved dramatically over time, but about 500,000 households remain offline or underconnected and many low-income households still pay above the FCC affordability benchmark. Ernesto Falcon of the CPUC Public Advocates Office said California’s market is losing its competitive edge, with prices higher than in other states and meaningful price pressure coming mainly from fiber competition at the gigabit tier. He said roughly 4.8 million Californians are limited to one gigabit option and estimated that more competition could save consumers more than $1 billion annually. Both witnesses emphasized the need for stronger transparency, targeted subsidies, and a permanent affordability solution, including extending and refining the CPUC broadband Lifeline pilot and advancing SB 716. Public commenters, including representatives from cable providers, nonprofits, and digital equity organizations, largely supported SB 716 and a permanent broadband affordability program. Several urged the committee to remove a cap on the Lifeline program, expand the CPUC pilot, and invest in digital navigators, outreach, and enrollment assistance. The hearing ended without a vote or formal action, after the chair thanked the witnesses and public commenters for their testimony.