Video & Transcript Research : 'irrevocable trust'
Page 165 of 461
HI
Transcript Highlights:
- practitioners, that OHA stands ready to provide consult, and I would hope, and I cannot speak on behalf of the trust
- practitioners, that OHA stands ready to provide consult, and I would hope, and I cannot speak on behalf of the trust
- practitioners, that OHA stands ready to provide consult, and I would hope, and I cannot speak on behalf of the trust
- practitioners, that OHA stands ready to provide consult, and I would hope, and I cannot speak on behalf of the trust
- practitioners, that OHA stands ready to provide consult, and I would hope, and I cannot speak on behalf of the trust
Summary:
The Committee on Water and Land met on March 13, 2025, and first announced that SB 1456 would be deferred to the end of the agenda and ultimately worked on later, with the chair indicating the bill would be deferred and revisited in a future measure. The committee then heard SB 841 on marine life conservation districts. DLNR supported the bill, saying it would fund carrying capacity studies to inform rules and policies. Testimony noted a pilot study already underway at the Puka Marine Life Conservation District and another nearing completion at the old Kona Airport MLCD. Members discussed costs, with DLNR estimating about $300,000 per year for one user-experience study, potentially more for ecological analysis, and also discussed possible funding from the Mālama Kai special fund. DLNR said it had no objection to consulting current operators and other users, and explained the program would be a new, ongoing adaptive-management tool.
The committee next heard SB 411 on capital improvement projects at small boat harbors. DLNR supported the intent, saying the bill would help expedite use of special funds for CIP work, while the Department of Budget and Finance opposed it, arguing the draft could conflict with constitutional limits on appropriations. Public testimony from an industry representative supported the bill and urged more collaboration with commercial operators, while committee discussion focused on whether DLNR could already use special funds for repairs, how much engineering and bidding work is required before projects go out to bid, and whether the current process creates bottlenecks when bids exceed initial estimates. DLNR said it can do some repairs and maintenance within existing authority and funding ceilings, but that the bill as drafted could be too broad.
The committee also heard SB 5 on historic preservation, where DLNR supported the measure and NAOP Hawaii opposed it, saying the bill’s broader definition could expand the scope beyond the stated goal of narrowing reviews and reducing backlog. The committee then took up SB 1462 on the state historic preservation income tax credit. The Department of Taxation said the revenue estimate assumes the cap would be reached each year the credit is available, and DLNR supported the bill. SHPD said the prior credit had sunset, outreach had previously been done in targeted communities such as Chinatown, and owners of eligible historic properties are notified during review. Finally, the committee heard SB 268 on island burial councils. DLNR supported the bill, and OHA strongly supported it, saying the councils have struggled with quorum and expertise and that the measure would restore the original intent of having lineal descendants and cultural practitioners as decision makers, while still allowing landowners and developers to testify and participate. OHA also said it would help provide technical support and urged continued involvement from SHPD and the Attorney General’s office.
MN
Minnesota 2025 1st Special Session
House Elections Finance and Government Operations Committee 3/5/25
Elections Finance and Government Operations
Transcript Highlights:
- if you've got you're guessing but if you've got someone<01:15:26.600>
you <01:15:26.760>trust - > says<01:15:27.639>
yes <01:15:28.400>they <01:15:28.560>did someone you trust - when people come in and watch from step A to Z, they understand it better, and there is a lot more trust
- when people come in and watch from step A to Z, they understand it better, and there is a lot more trust
- and faith and I think uh one more trust and faith and I think uh one of<01:18:33.239>
the <01:
MN
Minnesota 2025 1st Special Session
Committee on Housing and Homelessness Prevention - 02/06/25
Housing and Homelessness Prevention
Transcript Highlights:
- Block Grant funds, and HOME Investment Partnership Program funds, and some of us receive local housing trust
- ><00:03:51.840>
um <00:03:51.959>local <00:03:52.280>housing <00:03:52.599>trust - of us receive um local housing trust of us receive um local housing trust funds<00:03:53.480>
- Our rehab and real estate department, they manage the city’s Housing Trust Fund projects.
- this slide how we've deployed that money and where every single dollar goes in order for us to build trust
Summary:
The committee on Housing and Homelessness Prevention heard presentations focused on public housing and related funding needs, with testimony from Minnesota NAHRO and several local housing authorities. Melissa Taphorn described the role of housing authorities statewide, including public housing, vouchers, CDBG/HOME funds, Bridges, and HEAT, and emphasized that public housing serves over 36,000 low-income Minnesotans, many of whom are seniors, people with disabilities, or children. She said federal operating and capital funds are insufficient, creating deferred maintenance backlogs, and noted that Minnesota’s public housing capital needs over a five-year period were about $500 million, with nearly $200 million unmet. She also discussed federal uncertainty, including a recent HUD funding freeze notice, possible changes to fair housing requirements, RAD repositioning options, and Build America, Buy America costs.
Committee members asked about tenant rent calculations and the populations served. Testimony clarified that public housing residents generally pay 30% of monthly income, with utility allowances factored in, and that the average tenant rent in Minnesota is about $399. Members also heard that about 65% of public housing households are seniors or people with disabilities, while about 35% are families. The committee then heard examples of how state POP grants have been used to preserve public housing stock. Kurt Kina of the Red Wing HRA described multiple POP-funded projects that replaced windows, upgraded heating and cooling, and modernized electrical systems in a 100-resident high-rise, saying the work was essential to keep the building viable.
Louise Siba of the St. Paul PHA testified that St. Paul’s authority serves nearly 22,000 people through more than 4,200 public housing units and over 5,200 vouchers, with most townhomes and high-rises serving elderly or disabled residents. She said St. Paul PHA has received nearly $16 million in POP funding since 2012, including about $8.5 million last year, and that those funds enabled major life-safety and modernization projects such as the Denan Terrace renovation and boiler, plumbing, and interior upgrades in high-rises. Jill Keers of the Duluth HRA described a broader set of housing programs, including vouchers, rehab loans, emergency repair funds, construction training, and development. She said Duluth HRA is adding 128 housing units between 2023 and 2025, including mixed-income rentals, senior housing, and family townhomes, and stressed that state investment through POP and other programs is necessary to keep housing affordable and safe.
PA
Transcript Highlights:
- the National Prayer Breakfast and added "under God" to the Pledge of Allegiance, added "In God We Trust
- " to our currency, and made "In God We Trust" the national motto, and facilitated the addition of a prayer
Summary:
The House convened at noon with prayer and the Pledge of Allegiance, then postponed approval of the prior day’s journal. The main business was remarks by Representative Borowitz on House Resolution 579, marking America’s 250th anniversary and celebrating the nation’s founding principles. Her remarks emphasized the Declaration of Independence, natural rights, religious faith in American history, and a long list of historical examples she said reflected divine providence and the role of religion in public life.
No debate or vote on the resolution itself is shown in the transcript. After the remarks, the chair reminded members of the five-minute rule for speeches under House Rule 17. Representative Dockery then moved that the House adjourn until Monday, June 29, 2026, at 12 noon unless recalled sooner by the Speaker.
The motion to adjourn was put to a voice vote and adopted, and the House adjourned accordingly.
NM
Transcript Highlights:
- An act authorizing a transfer from the general fund to the Behavioral Health Trust Fund.
- Scheer, Campos, and Cedillo-Lopez, an act authorizing a transfer from the General Fund to the Medicaid Trust
CA
California 2025-2026 Regular Session
Assembly Utilities and Energy Committee Jun 24th, 2026
Transcript Highlights:
- As much as utilities say the right things about trying to reduce rates, there is a trust problem.
- Given those incentives, it's hard for the public to trust them not to favor expensive investments like
- I think they've earned our trust and ought to be empowered in this regard.
- that office. ...to, to, um, for me to trust that office to come up with, uh, not just recommendations
- My trust funds, my pension funds, are in constant contact with Moody's, with S&P, and this is what we
Summary:
The committee first heard SB 804, the Hydrogen Pipeline Safety Act, from Senator Arreguín. He said the bill would designate the State Fire Marshal as the safety regulator for intrastate hydrogen pipelines and require hydrogen-specific standards, while not mandating any pipeline construction or bypassing environmental review. Supporters included labor groups, utility employees, and the City of Burbank, while Air Products opposed unless amended, citing concerns about the bill’s specificity, fee structure, and the need for a hydrogen-specific rulemaking process. The committee discussed safety, fees, and regulatory certainty, and later passed SB 804 on a 9-0 vote to Emergency Management with commitment to take amendments.
The committee then took up SB 905 by Senator Becker, aimed at reducing electricity rates by changing utility incentives. The bill would tie part of executive compensation to keeping rates below inflation, require more performance metrics, and allow the CPUC to consider lower returns on equity for certain lower-risk investments and alternative financing options. Support came from consumer, environmental, agricultural, and large energy user groups, while Southern California Edison, CalChamber, PG&E, and utility labor groups raised concerns that the bill could reduce investment, create regulatory uncertainty, and raise borrowing costs. After extensive discussion about utility affordability, wildfire costs, and capital markets, the committee passed SB 905 on a 7-1 vote to Appropriations.
SB 913, also by Senator Becker, would create a clearer pathway for distributed energy resources such as batteries and smart thermostats to participate in the resource adequacy market and compete with utility-scale resources. Supporters said the bill would better use existing grid capacity, lower costs, and build on the state’s Demand Side Grid Support Program; PG&E opposed unless amended, saying the use case was not yet proven and was already being addressed in other rulemakings. After the committee accepted amendments, one opposition group moved to neutral and another said it might do so after reviewing the changes. The bill passed 8-0 to Appropriations and was placed on call.
Several other measures were heard and advanced, including SB 1196 on faster utility hookups for small energization projects such as ADUs and EV chargers, SB 931 reauthorizing the Diablo Canyon Essential Services Mitigation Fund through 2028, SB 1158 reducing the frequency of joint reliability assessments from quarterly to twice yearly, and SB 1245 directing further study of California’s gasoline market and potential use of non-CARBOB fuel during supply disruptions. SB 1196 and SB 931 both passed with broad support and no opposition after amendments, SB 1158 passed without testimony, and SB 1245 drew strong support from consumer and environmental advocates but opposition from fuel industry and business groups concerned about costs, confidentiality, and fuel standards.
MA
Massachusetts 2025-2026 Regular Session
Joint Committee on Economic Development and Emerging Technologies Jun 21st, 2026 at 12:30 pm
Joint Committee on Economic Development and Emerging Technologies
Transcript Highlights:
- And trust me, I thought a lot about this, but, you know, here's something for constituents to know: that
- And trust me, I thought a lot about this, but, you know, here's something for constituents to know: that
- pressures that we ask our humans. ...listening to trusted experts who can navigate the same complex
- We've developed trusted relationships with state, federal, municipal, tribal, and industry partners,
- That might sound simple, but it's really built on decades of trust building and relationship building
Summary:
The committee on Economic Development held a hearing on the DRIVE Act, a proposal to invest $400 million in Massachusetts research and innovation without new taxes. Governor Healey and administration officials said the bill would direct $200 million to public higher education research and regional partnerships and $200 million to a research funding pool for hospitals, universities, and other institutions, with the goal of retaining talent, leveraging private and philanthropic dollars, and offsetting major federal R&D cuts. They argued that research is a core economic engine for the state, supporting jobs across labs, construction, services, and surrounding businesses, and said the bill would help protect the Commonwealth’s tax base and competitiveness during a period of federal uncertainty and cuts to SNAP, Medicaid, and other programs.
Committee members raised concerns about whether Fair Share surtax dollars should instead be used for K-12 and other community needs, whether the proposal is enough given the scale of lost federal grants, and how the money would be allocated. The governor responded that the funds are one-time surplus dollars, that most surtax revenue already supports education, and that the bill is meant as a bridge to stabilize public higher education and research. She also said the legislation includes a review board and could support a revolving or matched-fund approach in some cases. Several members pressed for more detail on selection criteria, future funding, and whether private companies and large endowments should contribute more.
University of Massachusetts leaders and researchers testified that federal grant cancellations and delays are already causing layoffs, furloughs, rescinded admissions, and lost research capacity. UMass officials said the bill would help preserve faculty, postdocs, graduate students, and research programs in medicine, climate science, marine science, Braille instruction, and AI decision-making. They emphasized that the funding should be merit-based and that the state needs to act quickly to prevent talent from leaving Massachusetts. Business, labor, and industry groups, including MassBio, the Massachusetts Taxpayers Foundation, AIM, the AFL-CIO, and Building Trades, supported the bill, saying it would protect jobs, sustain the innovation ecosystem, and reinforce Massachusetts’ national leadership in research and life sciences. No vote was taken in the hearing.
MN
Minnesota 2025-2026 Regular Session
Suspend rules to take up HF3819 4/30/26
Minnesota House Floor Meeting
Transcript Highlights:
- Trust me, I know. I pay around $900 a week for my two kids.
- Trust<00:01:06.040>
me, <00:01:06.200>I <00:01:06.320>know. - 01:06.760>
pay <00:01:07.160>around <00:01:07.680>$900 <00:01:08.480>a Trust - I pay around $900 a Trust me, I know.
- ,<01:02:40.920>
to to start fixing it, to restore trust, to to start fixing it, to restore
Summary:
The House took up an urgency motion to recall House File 3819 from committee and advance it to final passage. Supporters said the bill was needed to address fraud in the child care assistance program (CCAP), citing recent FBI raids on child care centers, prior audit findings, and long-standing concerns about weak oversight. They described the bill as restoring a penalty of perjury for attendance records, requiring electronic attendance tracking, mandating unannounced inspections, and requiring camera monitoring for higher-funded providers so the state can verify attendance and reduce improper payments.
Opponents argued the bill was not ready, raised concerns about cost, implementation, and the inclusion of camera surveillance, and said the language could create problems related to retention and possible misuse of video. One member said the state had already taken bipartisan action on child care fraud in prior sessions and that the larger fraud estimates being cited were overstated compared with convictions. Another member emphasized that electronic attendance monitoring was the one part they supported, but said the bill lacked clarity and a Senate companion.
Members also discussed the history of CCAP fraud investigations, including earlier OLA reports, criminal investigations within DHS, and allegations that fraud vulnerabilities had been known for years. Supporters argued the bill would help recover taxpayer dollars and improve affordability by reducing fraud, while critics warned that added camera requirements could increase costs for providers and potentially threaten child care center viability. The debate included questions and answers about video retention, with the bill author stating the intended retention period was 90 days, though a member noted that language was not clearly visible in the version before the House.
CA
California 2025-2026 Regular Session
Assembly Budget Subcommittee No. 4 on Climate Crisis, Resources, Energy, and Transportation Apr 22nd, 2026
Transcript Highlights:
- , Sonoma Land Trust, Resources Renewal Institute, Pacific Forest Trust, and Power.
- Land Trust, Renewal Institute, Pacific Forest Trust, and Power Nature.
- Paul Mason, Pacific Forest Trust.
- Good afternoon, Chair and staff, Rico Mastrodenado with the Trust for Public Land.
- Good afternoon, Chair and staff, Rico Mastrodenado with the Trust for Public Land.
NH
Transcript Highlights:
- public hearing for SB 101, Senator Lang testified that we had $100 million surplus in the education trust
- <00:52:02.960>
fund <00:52:03.280>for surplus in the education trust fund for surplus - in the education trust fund for open<00:52:03.839>
enrollment. - to be identified for dyslexia, for a specific learning disability that I had been told, when I had trusted
- <00:53:54.880>
the <00:53:55.119>school been told when I had trusted the school been
NM
New Mexico 2026 Regular Session
Senate Chamber Feb 12th, 2026 at 12:12 pm
New Mexico Senate Floor Meeting
Transcript Highlights:
- It won't come from the early childhood trust fund or state fund.
- The trust fund's putting that $600 million a year.
- The money they're talking about is above trust fund money. So there's a lot of money out there.
- And the early childhood trust fund is predicted to throw off roughly $50 to $60 million a year? Mr.
- President, the early childhood trust fund right now at 10,000,000,000... Mr.
FL
Florida 2026 Regular Session
FL House Floor Session - 2026-02-11 (4:00PM Session)
Florida House Floor Meeting
Transcript Highlights:
- Parents have overwhelmingly said that they trust school libraries.
- It's called All Boys Aren't Blue off Amazon, because I didn't want to just trust the Internet on what
- The bill authorizes financial institutions to hold funds in attorney trust accounts used for purposes
- So thank you to the Speaker for trusting me and having my back on that.
- Thank you, Chair Buchanan, for trusting me to land this plane.
Summary:
The House convened with prayer, moments of silence for former member Terry Fields and the Parkland victims, the Pledge of Allegiance, and recognition of guests and visitors. The chamber then adopted the Rules and Ethics Committee’s special order report setting the day’s calendar and debate times. The main measure taken up was HB 1119, relating to materials harmful to minors in public schools and charter schools, which the sponsor described as a clarification of existing law to keep pornographic or sexually explicit material away from minors and to give districts clearer standards for review and objection processes.
The bill drew extensive debate over constitutional concerns, local control, litigation risk, and the scope of the definition of “harmful to minors.” Members supporting the bill argued it was needed to close loopholes and protect children, while opponents warned it could lead to overbroad book removals, conflict with federal court rulings, and costly lawsuits. A series of amendments sought to narrow or redirect the bill: proposals by Gant, Aristide, Bartleman, Eskamani, Nixon, Rainer, Woodson, and Harris would have preserved literary value review, protected educational and abuse-prevention materials, exempted LGBTQ-inclusive books, limited objections, preserved funding for districts, or delayed enforcement during ongoing litigation. Supporters of the amendments framed them as protecting parental choice, academic value, student safety, and district finances; opponents said they would weaken the bill’s child-protection purpose. All of the amendments failed.
After the amendment process, the House waived rules, read HB 1119 a third time by title, and entered structured debate on final passage. Debate continued along the same lines, with opponents emphasizing book removals, First Amendment concerns, and the impact on students and schools, and supporters reiterating that the bill was intended to prevent minors from accessing obscene material. The transcript provided ends during structured debate and does not include the final vote on HB 1119.
FL
Florida 2025 Regular Session
Rules Apr 21st, 2025
Transcript Highlights:
- THIS CAN PUT THE MINOR'S ABILITY TO TRUST THE MINOR'S ABILITY TO TRUST IN JEOPARDY AND ALLOW PARENTS
- RATHER THAN TRYING TO LEGISLATE GOOD PARENTING WE NEED TO TRUST FAMILIES WHO HAVE CARING TRUSTING RELATIONSHIPS
- UNITED STATES EXPERIENCED ACTUAL ABUSE. 90% OF CHILD SEXUAL ABUSE IS PERPETRATED BY SOMEONE KNOWN AND TRUSTED
- THIS ISN'T JUST A BEACH ACCESS BILL, IT'S A LINE IN THE SAND BETWEEN TRUST AND PRIVATE POWER THE LAST
- FEEL EMPOWERED TO CREATE A HOSTILE ENVIRONMENT TO THE POINT THEY ARE NOW TRYING TO TAKE WHAT'S IN THE TRUST
AL
Transcript Highlights:
- We come in this chamber today, and we see "In God We Trust" up here. That's not a mandate, right?
- Look, we got "In God We Trust."
- And I trust him in everything I do. And I trust him in everything I do.
- That's where I trust in God. Yeah. I don't, you know... Yeah.
- So I would trust that it would have some influence on actions for sure.
HI
Hawaii 2025 Regular Session
WTL Public Hearing 04-11-2025
Transcript Highlights:
- My primary duty as a trustee would be first to be loyal to the trust, to expose it to no harm, to not
- be involved with any conflict of interest, and to make sure that the beneficiaries of the trust are
- > trustee would be first to be loyal to trustee would be first to be loyal to the<01:00:01.000>
trust - :02.319>
expose <01:00:02.920>it <01:00:03.920>to <01:00:04.160>no the trust - to expose it to no the trust to expose it to no harm<01:00:06.240>
to <01:00:06.400>not
Summary:
The Water and Land Committee held a hearing on several governor’s messages for confirmation to land and water-related boards and commissions. The first item was GM 745, confirming Nor Abbott to a second term on the Natural Area Reserves System Commission through June 30, 2029. DLNR and other supporters submitted testimony, and Abbott said his focus has been on watching for potential impacts to marine reserves from nearby land activity and helping ensure those impacts are avoided, minimized, or mitigated through a thorough process.
The committee then took up GM 783 and GM 762, both involving the Kahoʻolawe Island Reserve Commission. Fenton Pang and Jensen Chop were nominated for terms ending June 30, 2028 and June 30, 2029, respectively. Multiple individuals and organizations testified in strong support, including representatives of civic clubs, Protect Kahoʻolawe ʻOhana, and other community groups. Testimony emphasized Pang’s scientific background, cultural values, humility, and service, and described Chop as a long-time Kahoʻolawe steward with strong ties to restoration work and the Protect Kahoʻolawe ʻOhana. Chop said his goal is to help more people build a connection to ʻāina and to continue restoration and cultural education efforts on Kahoʻolawe.
The final major item was GM 770, confirming Hannah Kihalani Springer to the Commission on Water Resource Management through June 30, 2028. DLNR strongly supported her nomination, describing her as a cultural expert and advocate who can ensure indigenous knowledge is meaningfully included in water policy. Testimony from community members, Earthjustice, Sierra Club, and others highlighted her experience, integrity, and role in protecting customary and traditional water rights, especially for place-based and Native Hawaiian communities. Supporters also said her appointment was important given current water and climate challenges. The chair indicated the committee would proceed to decision-making after the hearing, and no opposition was noted in the testimony summarized here.
MN
Minnesota 2025 1st Special Session
Committee on Environment, Climate and Legacy - 04/04/25
Environment, Climate, and Legacy
Transcript Highlights:
- That's what this permitting reform bill is about: restoring trust by making sure our permitting system
- <00:18:05.840>
away <00:18:06.000>at <00:18:06.240>their <00:18:06.400>trust - , level, it chips away at their trust, level, it chips away at their trust, their<00:18:07.440>
<00:18:14.559>Restoring <00:18:15.120>trust <00:18:15.440>by reform bill is - Restoring trust by reform bill is about.
NH
Transcript Highlights:
- LGBTQ students who deserve to be safe at school, deserve to have confidential conversations with a trusted
- have confidential conversations<00:06:19.960>
with <00:06:20.680>a <00:06:20.919>trusted - <00:06:21.840>
adult <00:06:22.840>um conversations with a trusted adult um conversations - with a trusted adult um and<00:06:23.199>
this <00:06:23.360>bill <00:06:23.720>is< - Some sort of sexual violence, and that disclosure may be to a trusted adult.
TX
Texas 89th 2nd C.S.
Appropriations - S/C on Articles I, IV, & V Feb 24th, 2025
Appropriations - S/C on Articles I, IV, & V
Transcript Highlights:
- Gary Gibbs: you'll see the latest news from the Texas Cultural Trust that you'll hear more about later
- ERS is a trust.
- It broke their trust. Some of those have come back but quite a few of them haven't.
- Research conducted by the Texas Cultural Trust shows Gabriela Cain: that academic achievement, school
- We also appreciate your efforts to reduce the unfunded liability of the ERS Trust Fund over the last
TX
Texas 89th Regular
Appropriations - S/C on Articles I, IV, & V Feb 24th, 2025
Appropriations - S/C on Articles I, IV, & V
Transcript Highlights:
- You'll see the latest news from the Texas Cultural Trust that you'll hear more. about later, the state
- The last item there is item 8, ERS is a trust.
- It broke their trust. Some of those have come back, but quite a few of them haven't.
- I'm here in partnership with the Texas Cultural Trust to support. Texas Commission on the Arts.
- We also appreciate your efforts to reduce the unfunded liability of the ERS Trust Fund.
CA
California 2025-2026 Regular Session
Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee Jun 23rd, 2026
Transcript Highlights:
- SB 898 creates a framework to structure disclosures and notices so that we enhance trust and security
- SB 898 creates a framework to structure disclosures and notices so that we enhance trust and security
- This response is essential to maintain public trust through transparency.
- It is the public trust and confidence in our decision-making, the public right to know.
- When it comes to government holding lists of Jews, we do not trust your privacy cart trails.
Summary:
The committee began as a subcommittee due to the lack of a quorum and heard several privacy- and technology-related measures. The first item was H.R. 117, a resolution urging Congress to reform Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act. The author and supporters argued the law is outdated and shields platforms from accountability for harms such as harassment, exploitation, scams, and other online abuse. Witnesses, including a survivor parent and a gender justice advocate, described harms to children, women, and LGBTQ people and urged a two-year sunset to force federal reform. Some members supported the resolution as a call for federal action, while one member said he could not support it because the resolution was too general and lacked specificity about the reforms being sought. No vote was taken because the committee lacked a quorum.
The committee then heard SB 898, which would require manufacturers of connected consumer products to disclose how long they will support the software and to notify consumers when products approach end of life. The author said consumers deserve transparency about security updates and continued functionality, and supporters from Consumer Reports and PIRG emphasized cybersecurity risks, consumer confusion, and electronic waste from unsupported devices. Opponents, including business and industry groups, raised concerns about enforcement through the unfair competition law, notice burdens, labeling issues, and compliance challenges, especially for products with long support windows or third-party dependencies. One member expressed support, noting the cybersecurity risks of end-of-life devices, but again no vote was taken because there was no quorum.
The committee also heard SB 435, which would narrow the CCPA definition of publicly available information to limit how businesses classify data as public. The author and supporters said the bill would close a loophole that allows data brokers and others to monetize personal information without meaningful consent and could help prevent surveillance and misuse of data, including by government agencies. Opponents argued the bill would upset the balance between privacy and the free flow of information, create compliance uncertainty, and retroactively reclassify information that businesses reasonably believed was public. Some members said they supported the goal of stronger privacy protections, while others said the bill was too broad. The committee again could not vote due to the lack of a quorum.
Later, the committee heard SB 923, which would expand Californians’ right to delete personal information to cover data obtained from third parties and require online businesses to offer a web form or similar method for deletion requests. Supporters, including the California Privacy Protection Agency and consumer advocates, said the bill would make deletion rights meaningful and better address data broker practices. Opponents sought an opt-out-of-processing alternative and raised operational and legal concerns, but supporters said deletion is not the same as retention or processing limits. Members largely spoke in favor of the bill’s privacy goals, but no action was taken. The committee also heard SB 947, the “No Robo Bosses Act,” which would require human review for certain automated employment decisions and limit predictive analysis in workplace discipline and termination. Labor groups supported the bill as a safeguard against biased or erroneous AI-driven decisions, while business, public employer, and local government groups opposed it as overbroad and burdensome. Members voiced support for human oversight in employment decisions, but the item was not voted on because the committee still lacked a quorum. Finally, the committee began hearing SB 1114, the SOGI Data Privacy Act, which would restrict disclosure of sexual orientation, gender identity, and intersex data to federal agencies absent a court order or legal requirement; the author and witness framed it as a response to federal efforts to obtain sensitive LGBTQ-related data.