Video & Transcript Research : 'arbitrary assessment'

Page 15 of 417
TX

Texas 89th Regular

Natural Resources Mar 26th, 2025

Natural Resources

Transcript Highlights:
  • Regarding the 20% threshold, it's arbitrary.
  • I think that can be done, but setting an arbitrary cap to begin with will ultimately deter investment
  • Could you elaborate on what assessment processes are in place to address those upgrades, and how they
  • To set an arbitrary cap, while well-intended, I understand, is a protection of ratepayers.
  • Well, again, that's the concern: is that setting an arbitrary cap.
MN

Minnesota 2025-2026 Regular Session

Committee on Housing and Homelessness Prevention - 03/13/25

Housing and Homelessness Prevention

Transcript Highlights:
  • These mandates are often completely arbitrary.
  • These mandates are often completely arbitrary.
  • These mandates are often completely arbitrary.
  • These mandates are often completely arbitrary.
  • These mandates are often completely arbitrary.
Keywords: 1187, senate, all
TX

Texas 89th Regular

89th Legislative Session Apr 15th, 2025

Texas House Floor Meeting

Transcript Highlights:
  • Language relating to makeup of a threat assessment team.
  • If the student under assessment is a special education student, this will ensure knowledgeable professionals
  • are involved. involved in the threat assessment teams.
  • a district to show that they provided notice to the parent of the student of both the threat... assessment
  • If we are assessing students for 100% mastery for It is imperative that we give students high-quality
MN

Minnesota 2025-2026 Regular Session

House Energy Finance and Policy Committee 3/24/26

Energy Finance and Policy

Transcript Highlights:
  • By capping interim rates at an arbitrary By capping interim rates at an arbitrary level,<00:20:47.600
  • So that seemed very arbitrary to me.
  • So that seemed very arbitrary to me.
  • So that seemed very arbitrary to me.
  • So that seemed very arbitrary to me.
Bills: HF4236, HF4122, HF4377
NH

New Hampshire 2026 Regular Session

House Ways and Means (02/09/2026)

Ways and Means

Transcript Highlights:
  • <00:04:05.680> and member companies were assessed and member companies were assessed and fronted
  • , this $35 million assessment, this $35 million assessment, well,<00:25:14.640> the<00:25:
  • offset the entire assessment. offset the entire assessment.
  • So<01:00:49.520> the<01:00:49.760> assessment So the assessment So the assessment the<01
  • So the assessment if a this right.
Keywords: 1189, house, all
MN

Minnesota 2025 1st Special Session

House Transportation Finance and Policy Committee 3/12/25

Transportation Finance and Policy

Transcript Highlights:
  • some some components in the assessment some some components in the assessment process<00:15:59.519
  • <00:21:11.559> a could we move forward uh assessing a could we move forward uh assessing a
  • <00:25:09.240> who's regarding the the assessment who's regarding the the assessment who's
  • statute required that the assessment statute required that the assessment take<00:25:19.520>
  • <00:28:30.880> or isn't subject to um being arbitrary or isn't subject to um being arbitrary
Keywords: 1183, house
NH

New Hampshire 2025 Regular Session

Senate Energy and Natural Resources (04/15/2025)

Energy and Natural Resources

Transcript Highlights:
  • It was a large list, about 15 to 20 factors that we had to assess.
  • Some you could that we had to assess.
  • Is that based on science or is that based on arbitrary like the 200?
  • um if if I recall arbitrary, right?
  • science or is that based on arbitrary science or is that based on arbitrary like<01:34:01.040>
Keywords: 1191, senate, all
NH

New Hampshire 2026 Regular Session

Senate Election Law and Municipal Affairs (01/13/2026)

Election Law and Municipal Affairs

Transcript Highlights:
  • There is nothing easy about assessing any of the criteria of the variance statute.
  • There is nothing easy about assessing There is nothing easy about assessing any<00:16:50.560>
  • Um, and fully arbitrary in our opinion.
  • Uh this is not an arbitrary<01:04:59.119> number.
  • Um this is because um arbitrary number.
Keywords: 1191, senate, all
CA

California 2025-2026 Regular Session

Senate Housing Committee Jun 10th, 2026

Housing

Transcript Highlights:
  • The assessment on vineyard parcels was first created by the Board of Supervisors in 2002.
  • Local growers vote to reauthorize the assessment every five years, essentially voting to assess themselves
  • The grower self-assessment covers about 30%, and the state's contribution covers about 10%.
  • My members continue to vote for this assessment because it's an example of success.
  • Cutting off housing assistance to these families based on arbitrary thresholds is cruel.
Keywords: 987, senate, all
Summary: The Senate Committee on Housing met without a quorum at first and operated as a subcommittee, then later established a quorum and took up several housing-related bills. Early presentations focused on AB 2390, a cleanup measure to clarify streamlined housing approvals and how modifications are reviewed; AB 1890, which would increase state matching funds for Napa County farmworker housing centers; and AB 956, which would clarify accessory dwelling unit law by allowing more flexibility in how ADUs are built and by clarifying application of ADU protections in common interest developments. Supporters for these bills emphasized predictability, farmworker housing stability, and expanded housing options for multigenerational families, while opponents of AB 956 raised concerns about neighborhood density, infrastructure, and local control. AB 956 drew the most extensive debate. Committee members discussed whether it was a clarification or expansion of ADU law, the potential for triggering density bonus rules, and possible local government costs. The author accepted committee amendments to avoid allowing a third ADU/JADU combination that could trigger density bonus implications. The committee then voted to do pass AB 956 as amended to the Senate Committee on Local Government, with one no vote recorded and the bill held on call for absent members. The committee also took votes on the consent calendar and on AB 2390 and AB 1890, but those measures were likewise held on call for absent members after favorable motions. The committee also heard AB 939, which would let developers transfer income-restricted ownership units to qualified nonprofit affordable housing organizations without waiting 180 days after certificate of occupancy. Supporters, including Habitat for Humanity and California YIMBY, said the bill would reduce vacancy, carrying costs, and help preserve long-term affordability. The California Association of Realtors opposed the bill unless amended, arguing it could limit buyer choice, codify first-right-of-refusal practices, and reduce wealth-building opportunities for families. After discussion, the bill was moved to the Senate Appropriations Committee on a do pass motion and held on call. Later bills included AB 1165, which would require state housing agencies to create a fiscal analysis and financial plan for ending homelessness; AB 1184, which would add transparency and open-meeting style requirements for homeowners associations; and AB 2035, a narrowly tailored measure to help Laguna Woods Village update outdated CC&Rs by lowering the vote threshold needed to seek court approval. AB 1165 and AB 2035 both received broad support and were moved forward on do pass motions, while AB 1184 also advanced despite late opposition from the California Association of Realtors. The committee then began hearing AB 1573, which would add survivors of domestic violence, sexual assault, and human trafficking to local housing element target populations, but the transcript cuts off before that bill’s testimony or any vote.
OK

Oklahoma 2026 Regular Session

Rules REVISED Apr 20th, 2026 at 09:00 am

Rules

Transcript Highlights:
  • concerned that this is putting the private School kids ahead of all the public school kids that need assessments
  • fiscal impact of how many people that would maybe not even be Determined to have a disability if the assessments
  • There are two big reasons: one, we don't have enough staff, people equipped and trained to do these assessments
  • even if you really want to help kids on the Lindsay Nicole Henry scholarship without doing the assessments
  • If you don't do those assessments, you don't know what to work with, and you're setting up for the kid
HI
Transcript Highlights:
  • health insurers talked about says that you shall conduct health planning activities of the state to assess
  • health planning activities of the state health planning activities of the state to<00:58:40.799> assess
  • c> address<00:58:42.079> gaps<00:58:42.480> or<00:58:42.799> concerns to assess
  • and address gaps or concerns to assess and address gaps or concerns affecting<00:58:44.400> access
Summary: The House Committee on Health heard testimony on a series of bills related to public health, pharmacy regulation, disability access, and health care infrastructure. HB 1535, creating an income tax credit for automated external defibrillator installations, drew support from the Department of Health, tax department comments, and public testimony emphasizing AED access in community and transit settings. HB 1765, requiring safety warnings for spear fishing gear, received comments from DLNR and strong support from a free-diving safety advocate who described blackout risks and argued for point-of-sale warnings. HB 1549, which would repeal the law prohibiting drug paraphernalia, drew mixed testimony: the Department of Health, the Public Defender, and harm-reduction advocates supported repeal as a public health measure, while HPD and a county prosecutor opposed it, warning it could encourage drug use and create public safety issues. The committee also heard HB 1550, which would exclude drug testing products from the definition of drug paraphernalia. The Department of Health and harm-reduction advocates supported the bill, saying drug checking tools save lives and help prevent overdoses, while one written opponent was noted. HB 1995, allowing people who are blind or deaf to receive disabled parking permits, drew opposition from the State Council on Developmental Disabilities, the Disability and Communication Access Board, and other opponents, while a few written supporters were also noted. HB 1671, allowing licensed dental hygienists to place interim therapeutic restorations in public health settings, received support from the Department of Health and several oral health organizations, with the Board of Dentistry offering comments. HB 1643, establishing a framework for pharmacy audits and record retrieval, prompted the most extended discussion. The Board of Pharmacy and independent pharmacy representatives supported the bill as a needed framework to limit burdensome audits and protect patient care, while HMSA raised concerns about possible conflicts with upcoming federal PBM reforms and potential unintended consequences. Committee members questioned both sides about timing and workload, and supporters argued the bill was needed now to protect rural and independent pharmacies. Finally, HB 1978, appropriating funds for a new outpatient care center in North Kona, received strong support from Hawaii Health Systems Corporation, Queen’s Health Systems, the Kona-Kohala Chamber, and others, who described it as a long-term investment in West Hawaii’s health care capacity and economy. No votes or final actions were taken in the portion of the hearing provided.
TX

Texas 89th Regular

State Affairs Mar 26th, 2025

State Affairs

Transcript Highlights:
  • that we take learning from the prior severe weather event and project a forward-thinking strategy to assess
  • Preparing agencies to assess and equip for severe weather events means that Texas can act strategically
  • You know, I talked about the human toll, but insurers have to rely on actuarial tables and assess risk
  • I think it is appropriate for state agencies to assess the changes in risk in different areas and different
  • And so this December, we posted our most recent long-term system assessment that did use a 10- and a
NH

New Hampshire 2025 Regular Session

JLCAR Administrative Rules (11/20/2025)

Transcript Highlights:
  • Is that a fair assessment of what we just said? >> Correct.
  • So it just seems like these are very arbitrary things to evaluate somebody on in that they could fall
  • Those were when it... some some arbitrary<00:21:13.360> implementation<00:21:14.320> of
  • <00:21:14.559> these arbitrary implementation of these arbitrary implementation of these categories
  • these are very arbitrary these are very arbitrary things<00:21:46.159> to<00:21:46.480>
Keywords: 928, house, all
Summary: The committee opened with routine business, including the Pledge of Allegiance, seating alternates, and approval of the minutes and consent calendar. Both were approved without opposition. The committee then moved to the regular calendar, beginning with Department of Environmental Services drinking water rules (2532). Staff noted that the final proposal deleted requirements that had been in the initial proposal, making the published notice technically inaccurate because it said there were no substantive changes. The agency responded that the requirements still exist in other rules, that regulated entities and the Water Council were notified, and that the public had notice through related hearings. After discussion about whether a new noticed hearing was needed, the committee approved the rule. The next item was Department of Administrative Services personnel rule 2510 on seniority and employee performance evaluation. Staff raised informational comments and one unclear comment about language that appeared to require a checkbox even though no form exists, and about evaluation categories that could overlap. The agency said the checkbox language should be removed, but defended the overlapping categories as part of a long-standing template used by agencies for the past 10 years. Members discussed whether the language was too ambiguous or could lead to inconsistent application, but the committee ultimately approved the rule with a condition striking the checkbox language in the affected sections. The committee then considered personnel rule 25109 on investigations, discipline, non-disciplinary communications, and non-disciplinary removal. Staff recommended clarifying language distinguishing license suspension from termination for cause, and questioned whether the sexual-harassment discipline language was too broad because the same conduct could fit multiple discipline levels. The agency agreed to add the suggested clarification for the license-suspension provision, but argued the sexual-harassment language should remain because another rule already provides the factors for determining the appropriate discipline and the agency needs discretion for fact-specific cases. The discussion included concerns about how non-verbal conduct might be treated, but the committee moved toward conditional approval with the agreed clarification and approval of the rest of the rule as written.
MA

Massachusetts 2025-2026 Regular Session

Joint Committee on Election Laws Jun 21st, 2026 at 01:00 pm

Joint Committee on Election Laws

Transcript Highlights:
  • It doesn't change any existing requirements, but ensures that sites are periodically assessed...
  • But for whatever variety of reasons they decided that they wanted to vote, the arbitrary deadline had
  • Arbitrary voter registration deadlines cut off registration at the precise time when voters are most
  • The 10-day voter registration deadline is an arbitrary penalty on working people.
  • cutoff. ...meal or a bed over filling out a change-of-address form by an arbitrary cutoff.
Keywords: 995, all
Summary: The Joint Committee on Election Laws held a hearing on a wide range of voting-access and election-administration bills. The largest portion of testimony focused on same-day voter registration (H. 834/S. 505), with support from Rep. Gentile, Boston and Chelsea officials, civic groups, and election administrators from Maine and Vermont. Supporters argued that same-day registration would help eligible voters who move frequently, miss deadlines, or face administrative errors, and would reduce rejected provisional ballots. Maine Secretary of State Shenna Bellows and Vermont elections director Sean Sheehan testified that same-day registration has worked in their states without major administrative problems and has helped increase turnout. A Boston-based panel also described high rejection rates for provisional ballots and the burden of registration cutoffs on renters, students, immigrants, and low-income voters. A second major topic was restoration of voting rights for incarcerated people, including S. 524 and related House bills. The committee heard extensive virtual testimony from incarcerated individuals at MCI Norfolk and MCI Shirley, who said voting should be restored as part of rehabilitation, civic engagement, and reintegration. They described disenfranchisement as dehumanizing and argued that voting would help maintain family and community ties, reduce recidivism, and give incarcerated people a voice on laws affecting prisons and reentry. Rep. Erica Uyterhoeven also testified in support, saying the bill would restore municipal voting rights for incarcerated residents and align with broader efforts to expand political participation. The committee also heard testimony on bills affecting election administration and access, including a proposal to reduce or eliminate mandated early in-person voting in primaries and shorten the general-election early voting period, with supporters from the town clerks’ community arguing that low usage, staffing burdens, and costs justify the change. Opponents warned that reducing in-person early voting could hurt voters who do not use mail ballots and could disproportionately affect communities of color. Other bills discussed included decoupling the municipal census from voter registration, requiring periodic accessibility inspections of polling places, and a Somerville home-rule petition on non-citizen municipal voting and another on lowering the voting age in municipal elections. No votes or final committee actions were taken during the hearing.
MA

Massachusetts 2025-2026 Regular Session

Joint Committee on Financial Services Jun 21st, 2026 at 10:30 am

Joint Committee on Financial Services

Transcript Highlights:
  • Unfortunately, you know, we have to pay drillers to do assessment.
  • There's a lot of arbitrary restrictions built into a lot of the policies, and we really should remove
  • There are arbitrary tests on cutoffs for blood values.
  • We know this treatment is indicated, but these arbitrary cutoffs limit coverage.
  • For example, insurance companies are not allowed to have arbitrary eligibility criteria.
Keywords: 995, all
Summary: The hearing opened with the Senate and House chairs of the Joint Committee on Financial Services explaining that the day’s agenda would focus on health insurance and other insurance matters, with a large number of witnesses and a request for brief testimony. Legislators were taken out of order to accommodate their schedules, and the committee heard testimony on several bills, including coverage for hair prostheses for alopecia (H. 1223/S. 832), medically necessary oral and dental care for head and neck cancer survivors (H. 1258), modernizing fertility and family-building coverage (H. 715/H. 1190 and related bills), coverage for prosthetic devices to support physical activity for people with limb loss (the “So Everybody Can Move” bill), remediation coverage for home heating oil releases (S. 813/H. 1302), and expanded access to physical therapy for Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (H. 1170). A separate bill on sickle cell care and registry development (S. 788) was also discussed by Senator Liz Miranda. Witnesses largely offered personal stories and expert testimony in support of the bills. Advocates for alopecia coverage described the medical and emotional impact of hair loss, the high cost of quality wigs, and the argument that scalp and facial hair prostheses should be treated like other medically necessary prosthetics. Cancer survivors and supporters of H. 1258 said oral and dental care after head and neck cancer treatment is a quality-of-life issue and often not covered despite major out-of-pocket costs. Fertility specialists, LGBTQ+ advocates, and legislators supporting the modern family-building bills said the current infertility definition is outdated and discriminatory, excluding same-sex couples, people needing donors or gestational carriers, and others with medical barriers to conception. For the limb-loss bill, parents and adults with prosthetic needs stressed that activity-specific prostheses are essential for children and adults to run, swim, play sports, and stay healthy, but are often excluded from coverage. The home heating oil testimony focused on the financial devastation caused by residential oil spills and the need to make spill coverage automatic in homeowners policies. Environmental professionals and homeowners described cleanup costs ranging from tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of dollars, the strict liability homeowners face, and the fact that many policyholders do not know the rider exists. The insurance industry testified in opposition to the mandatory-coverage approach, arguing for clearer distinctions between first- and third-party coverage, risk-mitigation standards, a delayed effective date, and more emphasis on education and notification rather than mandates. Committee members pressed the industry witness on why agents do not routinely tell customers about the rider and suggested that the issue may require broader disclosure by insurers, agents, and fuel dealers. No votes were taken during the hearing; the committee heard testimony and discussed possible compromise language and future action.