Video & Transcript Research : 'algorithmic decision making'

Page 157 of 500
AR

Arkansas 2026 1st Special Session

JOINT BUDGET COMMITTEE Mar 4th, 2026

JOINT BUDGET COMMITTEE

Transcript Highlights:
  • Does that make sense, sir? It makes some sense. I appreciate that.
  • which should be on your desk, it's a summary of appropriations that we hope will assist you in your decision-making
  • So you'll be looking at and making a decision on the appropriations for treasury, cash, and other appropriations
  • But still, I think the board has a right to make decisions that they think are best to help the universities
  • Basically, I want to make sure that steps are being taken to ensure that employment decisions remain
Summary: The committee first considered revisions to the JBC rules, which staff said were all prompted by acts passed in the 2025 legislative session. The rules were adopted without objection. Members then received a balanced budget presentation from DFA Secretary Jim Hudson on the governor’s FY27 proposal, which he said was built around three priorities: limiting state government growth, continuing investments in education, and advancing income tax cuts. He highlighted major additions for education funding, EFA growth, pay plan costs, higher education productivity funding, drug task forces, corrections medical costs, the governor’s 1033 initiative, SNAP error-rate reduction, and Medicaid sustainability, while also explaining a new A/B funding category structure intended to prioritize recurring costs and preserve room for tax cuts. Members questioned Hudson about the cost of income tax reductions, the constitutional balanced-budget requirement, education funding, the Educational Adequacy Fund, Medicaid trust fund balances, and the impact of federal changes on Medicaid and SNAP. Hudson said each tenth of a percent income tax cut would cost about $58 million, the budget remained balanced, public education would still receive historic increases, and the Medicaid trust fund would be monitored closely with additional set-asides proposed. He also said the FY27 SNAP administrative cost increase would be about $18 million. The committee then heard from the Division of Higher Education, which reported institutions were 2.61% more productive overall and that the budget recommendation followed the statutory productivity formula. Questions focused on why some institutions were receiving decreases or large increases, how the formula works, and how the new return-on-investment metric and committee composition would affect future funding. The committee approved several higher education-related actions, including personnel changes for nine institutions and special language for North Arkansas College’s move into the University of Arkansas system. Staff then walked members through the higher education appropriation summary, explaining large percentage increases at several institutions were tied to federal funds or corrected carry-forward issues, including the U of A School of Mathematical, Sciences and the Arts, South Arkansas College, SAU Tech, ASU Mountain Home, and ASU Newport. Members also discussed UAPB’s 1890 extension program and the University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture’s land-grant matching funds; officials said UAPB’s recommendation was being aligned with actual spending and that the Division of Agriculture’s Smith-Lever and Hatch matches were included within its overall appropriation. The committee ultimately adopted the Higher Education Coordinating Board’s recommendations for all institutions and then moved on to the Department of Corrections section, with the chair outlining how the committee would proceed through those appropriations by section.
HI

Hawaii 2025 Regular Session

AEN-PSM-EDT, AEN, AEN DEFER Public Hearings 02-10-2025

Agriculture and Environment

Transcript Highlights:
  • <00:14:26.120> making<00:14:26.480> until A's going to roll decision making until A's
  • <00:14:38.839> making<00:14:39.120> to Affairs will defer decision making to Affairs
  • Development tourism will defer decision Development tourism will defer decision making<00:14:51.320
  • c><00:21:29.679> till decision making on this one till decision making on this one till Wednesday
  • Okay, we shall go right into decision making.
Keywords: 912, senate, all
Summary: The hearing began on SP 547, which would create incentives for graywater recycling systems and atmospheric water generators through an income tax credit, a Department of Health rebate program, and building code standards. The Department of Health and Department of Taxation offered written comments; Taxation said it had seven proposed amendments to improve administration. Testimony was largely supportive, with advocates and local users describing water-supply benefits, emergency use during the Maui fires, and potential help for drought conditions and Red Hill concerns. The Tax Foundation of Hawaii suggested only the rebate program should move forward for clearer cost transparency, and the Department of Health said it needed more time to study the bill. Members questioned the fiscal impact and whether combining a tax credit and rebate was typical, but staff did not have cost estimates. Decision-making on SP 547 was deferred to February 12, 2025. The committee then took up SP 242 on foreign ownership of agricultural lands. The chair recommended passage with amendments, including deleting a reference to the Attorney General in one section and changing the effective date to July 1, 2050. Supporters argued the bill was a first step to limit foreign ownership of farmland, citing other states with similar restrictions, while several members said they supported the intent but had reservations about possible unintended harm to farmers and agriculture investment. After discussion, the measure passed with amendments on a 5-0 vote, with some members voting with reservations. The committee also discussed SP 1633, which would create a green building tax credit for structures using at least 30% Hawaii-grown hemp material. The chair said the bill was close but needed more work, and decision-making was deferred to February 12, 2025. Later, the committee heard several environmental measures: SB 683, which would ban intentionally added PFAS in certain products starting in 2028; SB 1109, which would replace the “finding of no significant impact” with a “finding of completion of environmental disclosure process”; SB 391, which would expand recycling requirements to certain lithium-ion batteries; and SB 12, which would classify neonic pesticides as restricted-use pesticides and limit certain seed treatments. Testimony on these bills included support from environmental and advocacy groups, comments from state agencies, and requests for amendments or further study, but no final votes were taken on those measures in the portion of the transcript provided.
DE

Delaware 2025-2026 Regular Session

Senate Legislative Session - Session 2 - 40th Legislative Day Jun 24th, 2026

Delaware Senate Floor Meeting

Transcript Highlights:
  • We relied on that legal precedent of the 1967 Supreme Court decision.
  • So let's keep making the progress and let's not take it for granted.
  • So we can probably tighten that up a little bit and make that a little clearer.
  • We're not making our streets safer.
  • It just doesn't make sense to me. I will not be supporting this vote or this bill.
Summary: The Senate received a large number of House communications and committee reports, including several nominations and many bills and resolutions returned from House committees or passed by the House. Committee reports covered a wide range of topics, including education, health, judiciary, finance, housing, transportation, emergency management, and business/technology. The Senate also assigned several measures to committees for further consideration and noted upcoming committee meetings. The chamber confirmed three nominations by roll call: Michael T. Scuse to the Delaware Thoroughbred Racing Commission, J. Eric Firewold to the University of Delaware Board of Trustees, and Joan F. Coker to the University of Delaware Board of Trustees. The Senate also passed Consent Calendar 66, which included Senate Concurrent Resolution 223 on DIA broadcast access for playoff and championship games and House Concurrent Resolution 149 designating June 12, 2026, as Loving Day in Delaware. Members discussed Loving Day and the importance of recognizing interracial marriage rights, with Senator Huxstable, Senator Buckson, and Senator Townsend offering remarks. On the floor, the Senate passed House Bill 141, requiring a firearm responsibilities notice for gun purchasers, after debate over gun safety and industry burden; House Substitute 1 for House Bill 200, as amended, expanding insurance coverage for HIV prevention medications PrEP and PEP; House Bill 426, modernizing municipal street-aid reporting; and Senate Resolution 21, directing a study of portable solar generation devices and related safety and utility issues. The Senate also passed Consent Agenda O, a large package of bills covering topics such as money transmission and stablecoins, nursing advancement, pilot licenses, commerce and trade, subaqueous lands, driver’s license loss due to medical issues, residential speed limits, electronic bidding, family court jurisdiction, agency regulations, technical corrections to multiple local charters, and other measures. The Senate then recessed until June 25, 2026.
HI
Transcript Highlights:
  • All right, seeing none, let's go straight into decision-making on these measures, starting at the top
  • into decision making uh on these into decision making uh on these measures<00:07:06.560> starting
  • Okay, so, Chair, do you want to just go into decision-making now? Sure.
  • Okay, we'll go into decision-making now. The recommendation is to pass SCR 89 and SR 72 as is.
  • okay go into decision making now sure okay go into decision making now sure okay we'll<00:31:19.399
Keywords: 912, senate, all
Summary: The committee heard testimony on HB 345, which would establish ʻōpae ʻula as the state shrimp. The Department of Land and Natural Resources and Kua Ulu Aumo testified in strong support, saying the designation could help protect endemic shrimp in anchialine pools and increase public education and awareness. In response to questions, DLNR said it would use existing education programs, press releases, and partnerships for statewide outreach and was not seeking a separate appropriation for that purpose. Members then took up SCR 132 and SR 111, which encourage adoption of recommendations from the UN Global Plastics Treaty and the Rapa Nui Summit Declaration on climate justice and sustainable development. Greenpeace Hawaii supported the measures, arguing that plastic production is tied to fossil fuel interests and that microplastics pose serious health and environmental risks. The committee later adopted the measures with amendments, including a change from “waste hierarchy” to “zero waste hierarchy” and technical edits. The final measures, SCR 157 and SR 127, urged the state to adopt and implement the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea agreement on biodiversity beyond national jurisdiction. DLNR testified that it had only just reviewed the resolution but stood on its written testimony. The committee passed SCR 157 and SR 127 as is. The meeting also included a separate hearing on SCR 89 and SR 72, which would create a University of Hawaiʻi Community College pathway for meat processing. The Department of Agriculture, Hawaii Farm Bureau, and Hawaii Cattlemen’s Council supported the idea, citing workforce needs and local protein supply, while several members raised concerns about whether a formal educational pathway or degree requirement might unnecessarily limit entry into the field; discussion focused on whether the proposal should be more vocational and whether there is enough data on workforce demand. No final vote on those measures was shown in the transcript excerpt.
NH

New Hampshire 2025 Regular Session

House Judiciary (03/03/2025)

Transcript Highlights:
  • the makes the face of it that makes the makes the judge<00:51:49.440> say<00:51:49.720> wait
  • that<02:38:32.479> said this decision but the decision that said this decision but the decision
  • <03:32:55.520> us that would make um that would make us that would make um that would make
  • <04:12:44.880> decisions<04:12:45.319> in sort of anyone to make decisions in sort
  • of anyone to make decisions in their<04:12:45.760> head<04:12:46.159> and<04:12:46.399>
Keywords: 928, house, all
Summary: The House Judiciary Committee met in executive session and first took up HB 148, which would allow classification by biological sex in limited circumstances such as multi-use bathrooms, certain athletic events, and involuntary commitment facilities. Supporters argued the bill was needed to protect privacy and safety, especially for women and girls, and said it was consistent with recent federal actions and prior legislation. Opponents said the bill lacked a clear definition of biological sex, could create confusion and discrimination, and was unnecessary because existing law and sports rules already address the issues raised. After debate, the committee voted 10-8 to recommend ought to pass on HB 148. The chair asked for a majority report and noted that a minority report would likely be filed. The committee then considered HB 254, a bill related to end-of-life medical decision-making. Supporters framed it as a matter of liberty and relief from suffering for terminally ill patients, while opponents raised moral objections, concerns about suicide being normalized, and worries about deceptive wording and death-certificate reporting. HB 254 was approved on an 11-7 vote for ought to pass, with the chair indicating he would write the majority report and Representative Perez the minority report. The committee then moved to HB 611 with Amendment 2025-0638, a replace-all amendment restoring prior law on recoupment of appointed-counsel costs from indigent criminal defendants and juveniles. The chair explained the amendment as reversing 2020 changes that had limited cost recovery, and the discussion focused on financial affidavits and the Office of Cost Containment’s ability to review indigency claims. The transcript cuts off before the committee vote on HB 611.
MN

Minnesota 2025-2026 Regular Session

Committee on Agriculture, Veterans Broadband and Rural Development - 03/12/25

Agriculture, Veterans, Broadband, and Rural Development

Transcript Highlights:
  • was making a sound financial<00:27:50.120> decision<00:27:50.480> to<00:27:50.640>
  • So the commissioner makes the final decision on who gets the award, and what does he base that on other
  • what does he make or she make that what does he make or she make that decision<00:30:38.000>
  • So what are the details of how he or she makes that final decision?
  • Dean, you said there are other people making decisions, and that made me think about the recent cuts
Keywords: 1187, senate, all
AZ

Arizona 2026 Regular Session

02/18/2026 - Senate Health and Human Services

Health and Human Services

Transcript Highlights:
  • It doesn't prohibit individuals from making personal medical decisions, and it doesn't criminalize providers
  • Section 1, Title 35, Section 35-196, is an assault on the right of Arizona citizens to make medical decisions
  • Section 1, Title 35, Section 35-196, is an assault on the right of Arizona citizens to make medical decisions
  • Why are you preventing adult citizens of Arizona the right to make medical decisions that are in their
  • This is because of bad information, and sadly, politics often replacing medical science in medical decision-making
Summary: The committee heard and acted on several health-related bills, with the longest discussion centered on SB 1214, the Arizona Stem Cell Therapy Act. The bill would regulate stem cell and birth tissue therapies, bar use of tissues derived from aborted fetuses or embryos, require informed consent and disclosure for non-FDA-approved therapies, and create civil and criminal penalties for violations. Supporters framed it as a patient-safety and bioscience-innovation measure, while opponents objected to the abortion-related language and felony penalties. The committee approved SB 1214 on a 4-3 vote. The committee also advanced SB 1194, which would prohibit health professionals and institutions from denying care or reducing care quality based on vaccination status, and SB 1814, which creates a study committee on substance use disorder treatment standards and oversight. SB 1602, increasing monthly stipends for kinship foster care parents, and SB 1603, expanding child-only cash assistance eligibility for certain foster and relative placements, were both amended and passed unanimously. SB 1177, barring public funds from being used for gender transition procedures, and SB 1014, requiring insurance coverage for detransition care and related reporting, both drew strong support and opposition and were each approved on 4-3 votes. Later, the committee unanimously passed SB 1628, requiring insurers and health plans to report claims-denial and prior-authorization data to DIFI for public reporting, and SB 1629, requiring AHCCCS managed care organizations to give advance notice and network-adequacy documentation before terminating high-volume providers without cause. Supporters of both bills emphasized transparency and patient access, while opponents argued the measures duplicated existing federal or state oversight. The committee then heard SB 1752, which would criminalize commercial harvesting or sale of mescaline while preserving a religious-use defense; the sponsor said it was intended to address improper sales of peyote-derived substances, but no final action on that bill was taken in the portion provided.
TX
Transcript Highlights:
  • I did make the decision to have one of those four meetings here in Austin because they have enjoyed coming
  • I don't want us to be in a position where decisions were made at one time that seemed to make sense given
  • And I, you know, that's a policy decision I think we as a body are going to have to make. ...But I think
  • **Chair**: We need to make a policy decision right now on what's going to be done to maintain both the
  • I'm making my point.
Bills: SB1, SB 1
FL

Florida 2026 4th Special Session

February 3, 2026 - 08:00 AM

Education & Employment Committee

Transcript Highlights:
  • And so I'm going to have to make a decision.
  • They need certain information in order to make the best decisions.
  • But I think overall, these folks need the information to make the best decisions.
  • So although it's important that board members have documents to be able to make sound decisions, because
  • I do agree that board members should, by and large, have the information they need to make sound decisions
TX
Transcript Highlights:
  • We make a lot of decisions from the dais, and we thought it was important to do those with integrity,
  • the organization can create a difficult dynamic. ...and decision-making, now that you're at the senior
  • to making harder decisions.
  • What we've tried to solve for is having no information asymmetry between when the board makes its decision
  • My feeling is that the board should be making their decision based on the exact same information that
Keywords: 1185, senate, all
MN

Minnesota 2025-2026 Regular Session

Hied Committee Meeting - 2025-03-27

Higher Education Finance and Policy

Transcript Highlights:
  • So, we are going to make that.
  • make sure that we're making the right decisions.
  • ; this is a we decision.
  • in the budget, this is a we decision.
  • And we can all see how that makes sense.
PA

Pennsylvania 2025-2026 Regular Session

House Session (Jul 1 2026)

Pennsylvania House Floor Meeting

Transcript Highlights:
  • Madam Speaker, this amendment makes several clarifications to the bill.
  • be present at all meetings of agencies and to witness the deliberation, policy formulation, and decision-making
  • Unfortunately, the recent decision by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in the case of Coleman v.
  • financial decisions that leave many Pennsylvanians wondering where their priorities lie.
  • This bill makes appropriations to the trustees of the University of Pennsylvania.
Summary: The House began with ceremonial recognitions, including guests of Representatives Benham and Warren and a farewell acknowledgment for longtime floor staffer Michelle Martin, who is leaving House service for a role in the Senate. The chamber then took up caucus and committee announcements, recessed several times, and later returned to consider a series of committee reports and bills. House and Senate bills were reported from Rules, Appropriations, and Judiciary, including referrals of several measures to committees. The House adopted House Resolution 515 unanimously, urging Congress to review Major Richard D. Winner’s actions for possible Medal of Honor recognition. It also adopted House Resolution 208, directing a performance audit of services, wait times, and processes in the Bureau of Blindness and Visual Services; supporters said it would help improve services for Pennsylvanians with vision impairment, while the vote was 201-1. The chamber then passed several bills with amendments, including measures on foster care youth benefits, AI companion safeguards, prison industry enhancement program administration, memorial bridge designations, firefighter and EMS donation options through PennDOT renewals, horse-racing background checks, and fertility preservation coverage. Several bills reached final passage. House Bill 1239, limiting homeowners associations from restricting rooftop solar installations, passed 109-93. House Bill 2146, amending the Sunshine Act to tighten the 24-hour agenda notice rule while preserving limited exceptions, passed 193-9 after debate over transparency and local-government flexibility. House Bill 2558, banning non-compete agreements for broadcast workers, passed narrowly 103-99 amid objections from Republicans and concerns about impacts on local broadcasters and contract rights. Senate Bills 971 and 972 also passed finally, dealing with township audit deadlines and municipal memorials for first responders. The House also approved House Bill 2412, funding state-related universities for fiscal year 2026-27, by 155-47 after debate over Penn State’s campus closures, accountability, and per-student funding differences; House Bill 2413, appropriating funds to the University of Pennsylvania, passed 195-7. The chamber then moved several bills back to Appropriations, signed Senate Bills 971 and 972, and adjourned until the next scheduled session.
MN

Minnesota 2025 1st Special Session

Committee on State and Local Government - 03/18/25

State and Local Government

Transcript Highlights:
  • Senator May Quaid to make sure that we Senator May Quaid to make sure that we uh<00:22:43.679> have
  • You know, they sit around a table at some point, the admissions people, and they make decisions about
  • You know, they sit around a table at some point, the admissions people, and they make decisions about
  • You know, they sit around a table at some point, the admissions people, and they make decisions about
  • Sit around a table at some point, the admissions people, and they make decisions about who should go
Keywords: 1187, senate, all
WY

Wyoming 2026 Regular Session

House Floor Session-Day 6, February 16, 2026-PM

Wyoming House Floor Meeting

Transcript Highlights:
  • to make that decision for everybody.
  • <01:42:26.320> that<01:42:26.639> decision single human being to make that decision
  • <01:44:26.639> those<01:44:26.960> decisions modif or I mean to make those decisions
  • do boundary is and make that decision to do boundary is and make that decision to do that.<02:38
  • receiving<03:32:46.880> a has to make a decision after receiving a has to make a decision
Keywords: 916, all
NY

New York 2025-2026 Regular Session

New York State Senate Session - 05/19/2026

New York Senate Floor Meeting

Transcript Highlights:
  • AND MAKE REAL IN THE LIVES OF ALL OF OUR SCHOOLS.
  • And I think about how the women, the 22 founders at that time, had to make a decision, despite the racial
  • But yet here we are making those changes now.
  • BUT, YET HERE WE ARE MAKING THOSE CHANGES NOW.
  • AND MAKE SURE THAT WE DON'T GO TOO FAR.
Keywords: 993, senate, all
Summary: The Senate convened, approved the prior journal, and handled several motions to discharge and substitute identical Assembly or Senate bills, along with a number of amendments. The chamber also welcomed student visitors from the League of Women Voters’ Students of Albany program and a group of Staten Island titleholders, and later adopted previously approved resolutions honoring Dorothy E. Reid for her role in Brown v. Board of Education and recognizing Delta Sigma Theta Sorority, Inc. on Delta Day, with multiple senators speaking in support of both recognitions. The bulk of the floor session was devoted to third-reading votes on a large number of bills, most of which passed with broad support. Measures addressed public health, workers’ compensation, education, environmental conservation, insurance, labor, criminal procedure, domestic relations, tax, municipal authority, and correction law. Several bills were explained by sponsors as advancing stormwater management authority, labor-law transparency, public health protections, and stronger penalties for trafficking-related offenses; one bill on immunization in summer camps drew a defense from Senator Skoufis as a child-protection measure, while another on correction law passed with some Republican opposition. The chamber also took up a controversial public health/electronic health records bill by Senator Fernandez. Senator Martin questioned the bill at length about redacting certain categories of information, emergency access, provider obligations, and the impact on doctors’ ability to see complete medical histories. Fernandez said the bill was intended to protect patients from discrimination and to limit access to a small list of sensitive services, while also noting emergency exceptions and support from more than 200 health care providers. The debate remained focused on balancing privacy protections with concerns about continuity of care and record integrity.
CA
Transcript Highlights:
  • And AB 3 enhances that and makes language changes to make it more broad.
  • Seems totally out of whack with when we need to be making decisions about what the plan is for this project
  • For us before we can make any decisions on this, and given your excellent point that we need to pass
  • We have that information to make some of those decisions with respect to funding for a project.
  • that you all can make the decisions that you need to make.
Keywords: 988, house, all
NH

New Hampshire 2026 Regular Session

Senate Education Finance (01/22/2026)

Education Finance

Transcript Highlights:
  • <00:47:10.160> in the rule make they do the rule making in the rule make they do the rule
  • ... continue to make.
  • better decisions.
  • Make it easy.
  • decisions.
Keywords: 1191, senate, all
MN

Minnesota 2025-2026 Regular Session

House Elections Finance and Government Operations Committee 2/25/26

Elections Finance and Government Operations

Transcript Highlights:
  • > to making certain decisions relating to making certain decisions relating to firearms<00:04:
  • It asks us to make difficult decisions. Love demands we do what we can to protect our children.
  • We want the cities to have their ability to make their own decisions on gun safety.
  • We want the cities to have their ability to make their own decisions on gun safety.
  • The whole point of local control is that every city can make the decision for itself.
Bills: HF3351
HI

Hawaii 2025 Regular Session

ECD Public Hearing - Fri Mar 14, 2025 @ 10:00 AM HST

Economic Development & Technology

Transcript Highlights:
  • event of a network failure, it may be necessary to reschedule the hearing or schedule a meeting for decision-making
  • we have uh a smaller decision-making we have uh a smaller approach<00:38:29.319> a<00:38:29.480
  • You know, we know you guys make a lot of decisions about the budget and everything else.
  • We are now back from recess, and we are going to start at the top of the agenda for decision making.
  • c> to<01:39:20.800> take into decision making we're going to take into decision making we're
Keywords: 910, house, all
Summary: The committee on Economic Development and Technology heard testimony on several measures, beginning with SB 1343, which would amend quorum requirements for the Small Business Regulatory Review Board. The board chair testified in support, saying it has been difficult to fill all seats and that using active seats for quorum would help the board function more effectively. No opposition or questions were raised, and the committee moved on. The committee then heard SB 1578, which drew mixed testimony. DBEDT supported the measure and the Attorney General suggested inserting preamble language from HB 1025 to provide historical context on the East-West Center. Austin Martin of the Libertarian Party of Hawaiʻi opposed the bill, arguing it could invite improper behavior, create loosely regulated satellite offices, increase foreign influence, and add competition for land ownership. The committee took no vote during the hearing. The bulk of the meeting focused on SB 1641, a measure to establish a Hawaiʻi film commission/authority and related funding and governance structure. DBEDT supported the intent and offered friendly amendments to clarify the distinction between film and media industries, while the Honolulu Film Office and labor representatives from IATSE, Teamsters, and Pride at Work supported the bill but urged changes. Their concerns centered on conflicts of interest, especially having producers on the commission, and they asked for more labor representation and clearer oversight rules. The Attorney General raised constitutional and special-fund concerns, saying the grant standards and special-fund language needed work. Committee members discussed renaming the entity as a Hawaiʻi Film Authority, broadening its scope beyond cultural production, adjusting the commission makeup, and clarifying funding sources, including the existing film and creative industries fund and the 0.2% rebate contribution. No final vote was taken in the portion provided, but members indicated the bill would need substantial revisions and an HD1.
MN

Minnesota 2025 1st Special Session

Committee on Environment, Climate and Legacy - 03/04/25

Environment, Climate, and Legacy

Transcript Highlights:
  • We want their perspectives as we make decisions.
  • We want their perspectives as we make decisions.
  • We want their perspectives as we make decisions.
  • We want their perspectives as we make decisions.
  • <01:09:57.640> of<01:09:57.800> the make decisions over the life of the make decisions
Keywords: 1187, senate, all