Video & Transcript Research : 'Second Amendment'

Page 120 of 500
NH

New Hampshire 2025 Regular Session

Senate Executive Departments and Administration (01/22/2025)

Executive Departments and Administration

Transcript Highlights:
  • <00:10:32.680> when here and you can do your amendment when here and you can do your amendment
  • Seconded. Discussion from the committee?
  • a motion on it move on to pass second a motion on it move on to pass second moved<00:35:44.920><
  • :35:46.359> the moved and seconded discussion from the moved and seconded discussion from the
  • Do we have a second? Second. All in favor? Aye.
Keywords: 1191, senate, all
NM

New Mexico 2026 Regular Session

Senate - Tax, Business and Transportation Feb 10th, 2026 at 04:43 pm

Senate Tax, Business & Transportation

Transcript Highlights:
  • We have a second motion from Senator Hadamio, second from Senator O'Malley.
  • So we are now on Senate Bill 21 with amendment.
  • Yeah, amendment. All right. Thank you so much. Is there any discussion on the amendment?
  • Is there any opposition to this amendment?
  • Madam Chair, just to be clear, it's a due pass on Senate Bill 21 as amended. As amended.
Bills: SB20, SB21, SB166, SB177, SB181, SB189, SM6
DE

Delaware 2025-2026 Regular Session

Senate Legislative Session - Session 2 - 42nd Legislative Day Jun 30th, 2026 at 02:00 pm

Delaware Senate Floor Meeting

Transcript Highlights:
  • I just want to make that clear because it sounded like he was not aware that that’s what the second amendment
  • 1 to House Amendment 1, House Amendment 1, House Amendment 3, and Senate Amendment 2.
  • House Bill 233 as amended by House Amendment 1, House Amendment 1 to House Amendment 1, House Amendment
  • House Amendment 1, House Amendment 1 to House Amendment 1 and House Amendment 3, 15 yes and 6 no.
  • I just wanted to point out that we do have a Senate amendment. One second.
Keywords: 1064, all
VT

Vermont 2025-2026 Regular Session

Senate Session - 2026-05-27 - 2:30PM

Vermont Senate Floor Meeting

Transcript Highlights:
  • That's the first instance of an amendment. >> The second instance of amendment, which has been foreshadowed
  • The second instance of amendment, which has been foreshadowed a couple times in the prior reports, is
  • government operations as amended? government operations as amended?
  • as amended.
  • as amended.
Keywords: 927, senate, all
AZ

Arizona 2026 Regular Session

01/28/2026 - Senate Judiciary and Elections

Judiciary and Elections

Transcript Highlights:
  • The second piece is when the person goes through the full 365 The second piece is when the person goes
  • The amendment is adopted. Please move the bill as amended.
  • The six-page amendment in your name, Person.
  • And the amendment.
  • The amendment is adopted. Please move the bill as amended.
Summary: The committee first approved the January 21, 2026 minutes and held SB 1208. It then heard SB 1211, which would allow victims of felony aggravated harassment involving domestic violence to seek a lifetime injunction against the convicted defendant. The sponsor said the bill came from fellowship participants, and supporters from the Arizona Coalition to End Sexual and Domestic Violence, Amberle’s Place, and survivor advocates testified that repeated harassment and re-traumatization justify permanent protection. The committee voted 7-0 to give SB 1211 a do pass recommendation. Next, the committee considered SB 1239, which removes the statute of limitations for failing to register as a sex offender. The sponsor said DPS requested the change to close a loophole and hold offenders accountable even years later. Opponents from Arizona Attorneys for Criminal Justice argued existing warrant and registration processes already address the problem and that eliminating the time limit raises due process concerns and risks stale prosecutions. After discussion, the committee approved SB 1239 on a 4-3 vote. The committee also heard SB 1240, which excludes probationers convicted of dangerous crimes against children from the probation incentive payment formula. The sponsor tied the bill to a recent child sexual assault case and said the incentive system should not count these offenders. Opponents warned it could push probation departments to send more people to prison instead of treatment and that the bill’s language is broad. The committee passed SB 1240 on a 4-3 vote. It then took up SB 1095, as amended, which bans gender transition procedures and referrals for minors and limits public funding and use of public facilities for such care; supporters framed it as protecting children and parental rights, while opponents called it discriminatory and medically unsound. The committee adopted the amendment and gave the bill a 4-3 do pass as amended recommendation. Finally, the committee heard SB 1243 and SB 1244, both dealing with court-ordered mental health treatment. SB 1243 requires notice to guardians when a patient may be released early or when treatment may not be renewed, and allows guardians to seek an independent evaluation and petition for continued treatment; supporters said it helps families prevent dangerous gaps in care, while opponents raised due process concerns about non-medical guardians initiating petitions. The committee passed SB 1243 unanimously. SB 1244 creates a continuing court-ordered treatment process after a second consecutive annual review, reducing repeated renewal hearings while preserving annual reporting and objections; supporters said it prevents dangerous lapses in treatment for the sickest patients, while opponents warned it could weaken due process and allow indefinite confinement. The committee adopted an amendment and passed SB 1244 on a 6-1 vote.
OK

Oklahoma 2026 Regular Session

Commerce and Economic Development Oversight REVISION 2: HB3127 - Added Mar 5th, 2026 at 10:30 am

Commerce & Economic Development Oversight

Transcript Highlights:
  • Seeing no questions on the amendment, we will adopt the Amendment.
  • Now we're on the bill as amended. You are now recognized to present your bill as amended.
  • Back to you on the bill as amended. You're recognized to present Your amended bill, thank you, Mr.
  • We're back on the bill as amended. Thank you. You're recognized to present your amended bill.
  • Sir, we are back on the bill as amended. You're recognized to present your amended bill.
LA

Louisiana 2026 Regular Session

Senate May 6th, 2026

Louisiana Senate Floor Meeting

Transcript Highlights:
  • House Bills on second reading: House Bill 198 by Representative Eccles is an act to amend Title 46 relative
  • With amendments.
  • Any amendments? No amendments. Close. Move final passage.
  • , 206 with amendments, 248 with amendments, and 441 with amendments.
  • , 210 without amendments, 305 without amendments, and 376 without amendments.
Keywords: 974, senate, all
AL

Alabama 2026 1st Special Session

Alabama House Insurance Committee Mar 17th, 2026

Economic Development/Banking/Insurance & Commerce

Transcript Highlights:
  • So, Representative Brown makes a motion for the amendment. A second. Dasher with a second.
  • the amendment.
  • c> second.
  • <00:11:34.240> All<00:11:34.399> in second. Dasher with a second. All in second.
  • favor report as amended. favor report as amended.
Bills: HB424, SB63, SB269
FL

Florida 2026 5th Special Session

Rules Apr 1st, 2025

Transcript Highlights:
  • That's the amendment. Other questions on the amendment?
  • There are no appearance forms on the amendment. Any debate? Amendment.
  • That is the amendment. Are there questions on the amendment?
  • And that's the amendment, Madam Chair. And that's the amendment, Madam Chair.
  • Is there any debate on the amendment? Is it a good amendment?
Summary: The committee took up a long agenda of bills, beginning with CS/SB 678, which would allow pawnbroker transaction forms to be printed or digital; it drew support from a business representative and was reported favorably. Members then heard several bills by Senator Leak, including SB 466 to designate St. Johns County as the site of the Florida Museum of Black History and create a board to work with the museum foundation and Florida Memorial University; the bill drew supportive testimony about preserving accurate Black history and the significance of the site, and it passed favorably. Leak’s CS/SB 578 would let Florida wineries use recyclable inserts and other alternative containers for larger wine sales, and it also passed favorably. SB 582 would increase penalties for unlawful demolition of historic buildings and structures, limiting the higher penalties to certain nationally or internationally recognized historic properties; it was supported by preservation advocates and reported favorably. CS/SB 1168 would create an aggravated offense for installing or using tracking devices or apps in furtherance of crimes such as murder, domestic violence, or robbery, and it passed favorably after a brief discussion about stalking and violent crimes. CS/SB 806 would make the Florida Attorney General the exclusive public official with standing to enforce Florida charitable trusts, limiting out-of-state attorneys general from suing over Florida-administered trusts; members debated whether this would burden out-of-state beneficiaries, but the bill was reported favorably. SB 1228 would advance spring restoration efforts for Ichetucknee Springs and Santa Fe spring flows and allow a utility compliance plan amendment to deliver reclaimed water to replenish the aquifer; it passed favorably. CS/CS/SB 304 would require a qualified medical opinion in child protective investigations involving infants and young children with possible genetic or medical conditions that can mimic abuse, and it drew emotional support from parents and advocates before passing favorably. SB 1286 would clarify that ordinary unsupervised childhood activities like biking or playing outside do not constitute neglect absent reckless endangerment, and it was reported favorably. SB 1318, the hands-free driving bill, generated the most extensive debate: it renames the texting-while-driving law, expands the prohibition to handheld device use, and adds penalties in work zones and school zones; supporters cited fatal crash statistics and personal loss, while opponents raised concerns about enforcement, civil liberties, racial disparities in traffic stops, and the need for broader distracted-driving and insurance reforms. Despite those concerns, the bill was reported favorably after amendments. The committee also approved two claims bills, SB 14 for the estate of Penao-Hanvier against Miami Beach and SB 20 for J.N. against Hillsborough County, both settled claims recommended favorably by the special master. Finally, CS/SB 68 would modernize health facilities authority financing for private not-for-profit health systems, and CS/SB 172 would restrict misuse of health care specialty titles while preserving titles authorized under existing practice acts; both were discussed with questions about doctors, optometrists, and CRNAs, and both were reported favorably after amendment and debate.
NM

New Mexico 2025 Regular Session

House - Energy, Environment and Natural Resources Jan 28th, 2025

House Energy, Environment & Natural Resources

Transcript Highlights:
  • First, you have an amendment. Do you have an amendment? I do have an amendment.
  • The amendment has been moved and seconded, so go ahead, Representative Block, explain your amendment.
  • The second part of the amendment is that you can't use a corporate energy storage system as a residential
  • Is there a motion to adopt the amendment? Is there a second?
  • As amended, we have a do pass as amended. That's the proper motion. Thank you.
NH

New Hampshire 2025 Regular Session

House Labor, Industrial and Rehabilitative Services (10/22/2025)

Labor, Industrial and Rehabilitative Services

Transcript Highlights:
  • So, we have a motion, we have amend, and we have a second on the amendment alone. >> Yes.
  • , we have amend, and we have<01:50:10.400> a<01:50:10.560> second<01:50:10.880> on
  • have a second on the amendment alone. have a second on the amendment alone.
  • Now, do we have a motion of ought to pass with amendment on HB 303? >> Do we have a second?
  • >> Okay, we have a motion and a second on ought to pass as amended. >> Are there any comments?
Keywords: 1189, house, all
FL

Florida 2026 Regular Session

FL House Floor Session - 2026-06-02 (10:00AM Session)

Florida House Floor Meeting

Transcript Highlights:
  • Second, the amendment reduces the annual assessment increase limitation on non-homestead properties from
  • amendment.
  • All right, seeing none, is there an amendment? Is there an amendment to the amendment?
  • All right, seeing none, is there an amendment? Is there an amendment to the amendment?
  • amendment.
Keywords: 998, house, all
KY
Transcript Highlights:
  • Do we have a second? Second, Senator Given. Please call the roll. Senator Carol, I.
  • And now it comes back with an amendment. Still not seen officially the amendment. Okay.
  • I got 30 seconds. Thank you. We should lop off this amendment.
  • Second. We have a second for Senator Tisher. Please call the roll.
  • Second. We have a second for Given. Second. We have a second for Senator<00:54:19.760> Tisher.
Keywords: 958, all
Summary: The Senate Education Committee heard House Bill 132, which would change home and hospital instruction funding so schools can be reimbursed sooner when students miss school for short-term mental health-related stays. Representative Nick Wilson said current law requires a student to be out five days before funding begins, leaving schools unpaid when they provide instruction during 2- to 4-day absences. The committee gave HB 132 favorable expression unanimously. The committee then heard House Bill 193, a cleanup bill on dual credit scholarships. Representative J.T. Payne and KHEAA’s director explained that the bill consolidates academic and CTE dual credit scholarships into one statute to reduce administrative confusion, since the programs have been funded together in recent budgets. HB 193 passed unanimously with favorable expression. House Bill 241 drew the most discussion. The committee first adopted a substitute, which members said changed the bill to give the Commissioner of Education discretion, rather than a mandate, to grant calamity days. The bill and substitute centered on virtual instruction and Cloverport Virtual Academy: supporters said the school was a pilot project that needed more time and that a prior agency effort to cap virtual instruction would have effectively shut it down, while opponents argued the substitute would reward a low-performing virtual model and extend NTI/virtual learning too broadly. Testimony from an Oldham County parent criticized NTI quality and opposed adding more virtual days. No final vote on HB 241 was included in the portion provided.
NY

New York 2025-2026 Regular Session

Senate Standing Committee on Housing, Construction and Community Development - 02/25/2026

Housing, Construction, and Community Development

Transcript Highlights:
  • I've got a motion from Senator Jackson, the second. Second. We'll have a motion to finance.
  • Second from Senator Helming and Senator Clear as well, backing up Senator Helming. Second.
  • Senator Salazar, second by Senator Clear. Any negative votes? No.
  • I've got a second from Senator Salazar. Any negative votes? No.
  • So we have a motion and a second. Thank you.
Keywords: 993, senate, all
Summary: The Senate Housing, Construction, and Community Development Committee met on February 25 and took up a series of housing-related bills, many of which had previously passed the Senate or been reported by the committee in prior sessions. Measures advanced included bills on NYCHA utility accountability, a small rental housing development initiative, uniform waiting list priorities for domestic violence survivors, protections for dependent children named in eviction papers, expansion of veterans’ housing preferences, inclusion of illegal conversions in the definition of harassment, repeal of obsolete rent formula language, inspection of major capital improvement rent increases and rent stabilization extensions, a community land trust acquisition fund, and an affordable independent senior housing assistance program. Most were reported to finance, Codes, or the floor, typically with some minority negative or “without recommendation” votes noted. The committee then returned to Senate Bill 6718B, sponsored by Senator Jackson, which would eliminate certain surcharges landlords may charge when tenants install appliances in rent-regulated housing. A guest speaker, Mr. Umberto Lopez, argued the bill would further squeeze landlords, especially small property owners, and warned that rising costs and regulation could lead to more units being taken off the market or “warehoused.” Committee members asked about the bill’s practical effect, including whether tenants could install appliances only with landlord approval and how current surcharge amounts are calculated for air conditioners, washers, dryers, and dishwashers. The chair explained that the bill would remove the ability to charge those existing fees, which are intended to cover wear and tear and utility-related costs. After the discussion, the committee voted to report S6718B, with minority negative votes recorded. The chair also noted an upcoming housing budget hearing later that day and repeatedly emphasized time limits during the meeting.
NH

New Hampshire 2025 Regular Session

Senate Education (02/18/2025)

Education

Transcript Highlights:
  • I have a motion to pass on the amendment and have a second.
  • I have a motion to pass on the amendment and have a second.
  • We'll pass it with the amendment. 376 want to pass as amended. Any further discussion? Second.
  • I have a motion to pass on the amendment and have a second. All those in favor of the amendment?
  • We'll pass it with the amendment. 376 want to pass as amended. Any further discussion? Second.
Keywords: 1191, senate, all
HI
Transcript Highlights:
  • And then I recommend that we amend the bill to adopt amendments proposed by AIA to broaden the urban
  • programs uh all of those amendments programs uh all of those amendments above<00:13:42.560> were
  • the bill to recommend that we amend the bill to adopt<00:13:49.639> amendments<00:13:50.199><
  • quarter of 2024 this was our the second quarter of 2024 this was our second<00:43:24.119> most
  • <01:26:06.560> for we're going to do Tech amendments for we're going to do Tech amendments
Keywords: 910, house, all
Summary: The House Committee on Transportation heard several bills on March 11, including measures on harbor vessel requirements, transportation funding, clean fuels, water carriers, parking enforcement, and electric mobility. For SB 1402 SD1 on vessels in state commercial harbors, testimony was split: the General Contractors Association of Hawaii and the Longline Association supported it, while Hol Holo Charters and one individual opposed it, saying the bill should be more specific about tourboat operators. For SB 1473 on central services assessments, SB 321 on privately owned roads, and SB 419 on insurance coverage for child passenger restraint systems, the committee heard brief testimony with no noted objections or actions beyond moving through the agenda. For SB 1009 SD2 on parking, the bill would create fines for misuse of disability and EV parking spaces and direct the revenue to the Safe Routes to School special fund. Support came from Ulupono Initiative, Climate Protectors Hawaii, the Disability Communication Access Board, and others, while the Retail Merchants of Hawaii supported the bill’s intent but questioned using the fines for Safe Routes to School, and Hawaiian Electric suggested directing EV-related fines to the EV charging system subaccount instead. Hawaii Appleseed supported the measure but raised concerns about the size of the fines and possible impacts on low-income residents. The committee asked questions about enforcement when EV chargers are inoperable; DAGS indicated the stalls could be used and would not be enforced in that situation. For SB 1120 on a clean fuel standard, the Department of Transportation supported the measure but asked for the implementation date to be delayed by one year and requested an independent Hawaii-specific economic impact study due before the next session. Support also came from several transportation, airline, and industry groups, while Tim Rhymer and Frank Schultz opposed it. The committee then heard SB 21 on water carriers, which would authorize a PUC inflationary cost index adjustment mechanism and exemptions; DOT, the Chamber of Commerce Hawaii, Young Brothers, and the Hawaii Harbors Users Group supported it, while Frank Schultz opposed. Finally, the committee heard SB 117 on electric mobility, which would expand and rename the rebate program, set age limits and operating rules for e-bikes and electric motorcycles, require insurance for electric motorcycle operators, and make conforming changes. Testimony was largely supportive, including from DOT, the Hawaii Bicycling League, the Queen’s pediatric trauma center, and Ulupono Initiative, though one testifier warned that the bill’s wattage definition could unintentionally capture some pedal-assist e-bikes. No votes were taken on the individual bills in the portions shown, and the transcript ended with the committee continuing its hearing agenda.
TX

Texas 89th Regular

Texas Ethics Commission Jun 12th, 2025

Texas House Floor Meeting

Transcript Highlights:
  • This change will basically give them until their second missed report, or second semi-annual report,
  • I have a second. Second by Commissioner Gorman.
  • On the second one. On the second one, OK. We have six different advisory opinions to discuss today.
  • Second. Vice Chair Flood moves to waive. Commissioner Slovutchuk seconds. All in favor?
  • I second. OK. Commissioner Slovitchek moves to reduce the fine to $1,500. Vice Chair Flood seconds.
CA
Transcript Highlights:
  • Do we have a second? I'll second the bill. Any further questions or comments?
  • Do we have a second? I'll second the motion. Someone would like to close, please.
  • Okay, we do have a motion on the floor, but a second, a motion and a second.
  • Second. Thank you. Mr.
  • Do we have a second? Second by Mr. Muratsuchi.
Summary: The Assembly Higher Education Committee heard a series of bills focused on expanding access to higher education, addressing workforce shortages, student housing, and labor standards on campus projects. AB 662 would create a South County Higher Education Task Force to explore a mixed-use, intersegmental institution in Chula Vista; supporters said South San Diego County is a “college desert,” while the bill passed on a due pass as amended motion to Appropriations. AB 885 would establish a College Access for All Fund to help make CSU and UC attendance more affordable; supporters cited student debt and affordability concerns, and it also passed to Appropriations. AB 730 would provide $15 million to help establish a medical school in the Central Valley to address physician shortages, and it advanced on a due pass motion. AB 1400 would let up to 15 community college districts pilot bachelor’s degrees in nursing; supporters argued it would expand affordable BSN access and keep students local, while CSU, UC, and other higher education groups opposed it as unnecessary and inconsistent with the master plan. The bill passed to Appropriations, with members raising questions about clinical placements, faculty shortages, and possible effects on associate-degree programs. The committee also considered AB 1235, which would require CSU design-build projects to use a skilled and trained workforce, aligning CSU with other public higher education construction standards. Supporters said it would improve safety, training, and local job opportunities, and the bill passed to Appropriations. AB 1247 would restrict contracting out of classified school and community college jobs unless workers meet training and qualification standards and would address pension and training concerns; supporters said it would protect students and classified employees, while school and college groups warned it would disrupt services and add unfunded mandates. The bill passed to Appropriations with one no vote. AB 1470, presented on behalf of Assemblymember Haney, would allow a portion of student housing revolving loan funds to be used for affordable student, faculty, and staff housing in downtown and commercial districts; it was discussed as a housing and downtown revitalization measure, but the committee held off on a motion pending more members. ACA 3, also on behalf of Haney, would require UC to offer limited down payment loans to eligible long-term support staff first-time homebuyers; it drew extensive support from UC workers and unions, while UC and business groups opposed it as costly and outside UC’s mission, and the measure was still under discussion at the end of the transcript.
FL

Florida 2026 Regular Session

Criminal Justice Nov 18th, 2025

Criminal Justice

Transcript Highlights:
  • There's a delete-all amendment. Would you like to take up the delete-all amendment now, Senator?
  • Amendment barcode 453182 by Senator Sharif. You're recognized to explain the amendment.
  • That's what this amendment does.
  • That's what this amendment does.
  • Without objection, we'll show that the amendment is adopted. We are now on the bill as amended.
Summary: The Criminal Justice Committee met with a quorum present and temporarily postponed SB 156. The committee first considered the confirmation of Matthew Walsh as Secretary of the Department of Juvenile Justice. Walsh described his background in law enforcement, social work, and juvenile justice, and outlined DJJ priorities including recruitment and retention, staff wellness, collaboration with DCF and other agencies, aging facilities, and expanding educational and vocational opportunities for youth. Members asked about his social work training, lockout youth, bed space, recidivism, and the Florida Scholars Academy. The committee voted unanimously to favorably report his confirmation. The committee then took up SPB 704, a committee bill extending the public records exemption for conviction integrity unit reinvestigation information. Senator Martin explained that the exemption was originally created to protect active innocence reviews and should continue past its current sunset date. With no opposition or debate, the committee voted unanimously to report the bill favorably as a committee bill. Next, the committee considered CS for SB 32, as amended, which creates an injunction for protection against serious violence by a known person and adds it to the statewide injunction verification system and related enforcement provisions. Senator Sharif said the bill is intended to give judges a faster tool to protect victims who have reported serious violence to law enforcement, while supporters said it addresses cases where victims are harmed before a repeat-violence injunction can be granted. Eric Friday of Florida Carry opposed the bill, warning it could be misused against self-defense situations and create problems in cases already covered by existing injunction laws. After debate, the committee voted unanimously to report the bill favorably. The committee then considered SB 210, which extends public records protections to petitions for injunctions for protection against serious violence by a known person, including dismissed petitions and identifying information before service. There was no opposition, and the committee voted unanimously to report SB 210 favorably before adjourning.
CA
Transcript Highlights:
  • Do we have a motion and a second on this? Okay. Okay, motion. We do need a second.
  • Do we have a second? Second.
  • Do we have a second? Second from Ms. Colosa. All right. Thank you, Chair.
  • Second? Second. Okay. Second by Wilson. Motion to pass to the Committee on Local Government.
  • Item number 13, motion and a second. Moved by Garcia. Seconded by Wicks.
Summary: The committee heard several housing-related bills, beginning with SB 1003, which would create pro-housing enhanced infrastructure financing districts to help local governments fund infrastructure needed for housing developments. The author and supporters argued that infrastructure costs often prevent projects from penciling out, while the chair expressed support and said the bill would be taken up later when quorum was available. SB 1014 followed, proposing new disclosure requirements for local jurisdictions to provide good-faith estimates of on-site and off-site improvements within 30 days of application, with supporters saying it would reduce late surprises and opposition from several cities citing implementation concerns with the 30-day timelines. The committee then took up SB 802, a Sacramento-region bill requiring a joint powers authority to coordinate housing and homelessness services. Senator Ashby and former Mayor Darrell Steinberg argued that Sacramento’s fragmented system has failed for years and that a JPA would improve accountability, coordination, and use of state funds. The bill drew broad support from local officials, service providers, business groups, and advocates, while some county and city representatives registered opposition or neutral concerns about state-mandated local governance. Several committee members said they were persuaded by the need for regional coordination, though some raised concerns about local control; the chair noted the bill would be moved when quorum allowed. The committee also heard SB 1092 and SB 1093, both focused on mobile home park residents after disasters or park sales. SB 1092 would give residents a right of first opportunity to match a sale offer for a park, with supporters saying it protects vulnerable seniors and preserves affordable housing, while park owners and their representatives argued it would devalue property and raise constitutional and financing concerns. SB 1093 would require more transparent communication, access to property, and consideration of rebuilding or closure after a disaster; supporters cited the long uncertainty faced by Palisades residents, while opponents warned about liability, safety, and burdensome review requirements. Members split along similar lines, with some emphasizing property rights and market impacts and others stressing the need to protect residents and preserve scarce affordable housing.